Genealogy in doubt

Started by Timothy Ellsworth Wilder on Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Participants:

  • Timothy Ellsworth Wilder
    Geni member
Timothy Ellsworth Wilder
5/19/2010 at 7:52 PM

This tree follows the genealogy in The Clan of the Tomkyns. A different genealogy is in Families of Little Compton which makes Gilbert and Michael the sons of Benjamin Tompkins of Little Compton. No evidence is given. The genealogy of Clan is preferred here because it matches circumstantial evidence better and seems more plausible.

The Mayflower Society and John Alden Society follow the Little Compton genealogy and then add wrong information about his place of death by confusing Clinton Corners, Dutchess county with Clinton Oneida county. His death in Dutchess county is confirmed by the fact that he lived there, his deathbed baptism was performed there, he was buried there and his will was probated there.

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion