John Coalter Bates (1844 - 1893)

‹ Back to Bates surname

View John Coalter Bates's complete profile:

  • See if you are related to John Coalter Bates
  • Request to view John Coalter Bates' family tree


Birthplace: St. Charles County, Missouri
Death: Died in San Diego, California
Managed by: Doug Robinson
Last Updated:

About John Coalter Bates

Edward Bates (September 4, 1793 – March 25, 1869) was a U.S. lawyer and statesman. He served as United States Attorney General under Abraham Lincoln from 1861 to 1864. He was the younger brother of Frederick Bates, second governor of Missouri, and James Woodson Bates, who was an attorney and politician in Arkansas.



[edit] Biography

Born in Goochland County, Virginia on his family's Belmont plantation, Bates was tutored at home as a boy. When older, he attended Charlotte Hall Military Academy in Maryland.

[edit] Career

Edward Bates served in the War of 1812 before moving to St. Louis, Missouri Territory in 1814 with his older brother James, who started working as an attorney. Frederick Bates was already in St. Louis by that time, where he had served as Secretary of the Louisiana Territory and Secretary of the Missouri Territory.

Edward Bates studied the law with Rufus Easton and boarded with his family. Easton was Judge of the Louisiana Territory, the largest jurisdiction in U.S. history after the Louisiana Purchase. After being admitted to the bar, Bates worked as a partner with Easton.[1]

In 1817 the two organized the James Ferry, which ran from St. Charles, Missouri to Alton, Illinois. Easton had founded the latter town, naming it after his first son Alton.[1]

Bates's private practice partner was Joshua Barton, who would be the first Missouri Secretary of State. Barton became infamous for fighting duels on Bloody Island (Mississippi River). In 1816 Bates was the second to Barton in a duel with Thomas Hempstead, brother of Edward Hempstead, the Missouri Territory's first Congressional representative. The fight ended without bloodshed. Barton would be killed in a duel on the island in 1823.

Bates' first foray into politics came in 1820, when he was elected as a member of the state's constitutional convention. He wrote the preamble to the state constitution—an honor that later influenced his fight against the radical Missouri Constitution of 1865. He next was appointed as the new state's attorney general.

In 1822, Bates was elected to the Missouri House of Representatives. He moved up to the United States House of Representatives for a single term (1827–1829). He was elected to the State Senate from 1831 to 1835, then to the Missouri House from 1835. He ran for the U.S. Senate, but lost to Democrat Thomas Hart Benton.

Lincoln met with his Cabinet for the first reading of the "Emancipation Proclamation" draft on July 22, 1862. L-R: Edwin M. Stanton, Salmon P. Chase, Abraham Lincoln, Gideon Welles, Caleb B. Smith, William H. Seward, Montgomery Blair and Edward Bates. Bates became a prominent member of the Whig Party during the 1840s, where his political philosophy closely resembled that of Henry Clay. During this time, he became interested in the case of the slave Polly Berry, who in 1843 gained her freedom decades after having been held illegally in the free state of Illinois for several months. Bates argued as her attorney in the separate freedom suit which she filed for her daughter Lucy Berry, then about age 14. According to the principle of partus sequitur ventrem, since the mother had been proved a free woman at the time of her daughter's birth, Lucy also gained her freedom.[2] During this time, Orion Clemens, brother of Mark Twain, studied law under Bates.

In 1850 President Millard Fillmore asked Bates to serve as U.S. Secretary of War, but he declined. Charles Magill Conrad accepted the position. At the Whig National Convention in 1852, Bates was considered for the vice-presidential slot on the ticket, and he led on the first ballot before losing on the second ballot to William Alexander Graham.

After the breakup of the Whig Party in the 1850s, Bates became a Republican, and was one of the four main candidates for the party's 1860 presidential nomination. He received support from Horace Greeley, who later switched to supporting Abraham Lincoln.[3] The next year, after winning the election, Lincoln appointed Bates as his Attorney General, an office Bates held from 1861 until 1864. Bates was the first Cabinet member to hail from the region west of the Mississippi River.

[edit] Attorney General

Bates's tenure as Attorney General generally met with mixed reviews. On the one hand, he was important in carrying out some of Lincoln's earlier war policies, including the arbitrary arrest of southern sympathizers and seditious northerners. On the other hand, as Lincoln's policies became more radical, Bates became increasingly irrelevant. Bates disagreed with Lincoln on emancipation and the recruitment of blacks into the Union Army. In 1864, Lincoln nominated Salmon P. Chase to be Chief Justice, an office which Bates had wanted, and he decided to resign his office.

[edit] Later activities

Bates returned to Missouri after leaving the cabinet. He participated in the conservative struggle against the adoption of the Missouri constitution of 1865. He authored seven essays arguing against the constitution. He particularly objected to the "ironclad oath" required as a proof of loyalty, and the disfranchisement of rebel sympathizers. But his efforts proved unsuccessful.

After the new constitution was ratified in the summer of 1865, Bates retired from politics altogether. He provided commentary on political events in the local newspapers, but never again played a prominent role in public policy. He died in St. Louis in 1869.

[edit] Marriage and family

Bates married Miss Julia Coalter from South Carolina. They had 17 children together.[3] Her brother David Coalter lived in St. Louis, and her sister Caroline J. Coalter married Hamilton R. Gamble, another attorney of the city, who became the chief justice of the State Supreme Court.[4]

Bates was, for the most part, happy with his large family. During the Civil War, his son Fleming Bates served with the Confederates, under the command of General Sterling Price. This was a cause of tension between the father and the son, and Bates rarely mentioned Fleming in his war-time diary. Another son, John C. Bates, served in the US Army and later became Army Chief of Staff. The youngest son, Charles, was still at West Point during the war.

-------------------- United States Army Chief of Staff. The son of US Attorney General Edward Bates, he was educated at Washington University in St. Louis and joined the Army, first as a First Lieutenant in the 11th United States Infantry Regiment then as an aide to General George G. Meade, serving throughout the Civil War and attaining the temporary rank of Lieutenant Colonel for his bravery and meritorious service at Gettysburg and other battles. He remained in the Army after the war, serving in the western United States during the Indian Wars and achieving the rank of Colonel as commander of 2nd United States Infantry in 1892.

During the Spanish-American War Bates commanded a division in Cuba as a Brigadier General and served as Military Governor of Cienfuegos, later traveling to the Philippines, where he negotiated a treaty with the Sultan of Sulu that established Moro neutrality and enabled the US to establish outposts in the southern Philippine Islands. Bates then commanded 1st Division, VIII Corps in Luzon, Philippines, afterward advancing to corps commander. From 1901 to 1904 he commanded the Department of the Missouri at Ft. Leavenworth, Kansas and then the Department of the Lakes in Detroit with the rank of Major General, and in 1905 he became commander of the Army's Northern Division in St. Louis.

In January 1906 Bates was appointed Army Chief of Staff, receiving promotion to Lieutenant General and serving until he reached mandatory retirement age in April 1906. From 1909 to 1911 he served as commander of the Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States.

view all

John C. Bates, Army Chief of Staff's Timeline

St. Charles County, Missouri
Age 49
San Diego, California
Arlington National Cemetery Arlington Arlington County Virginia