Start My Family Tree Welcome to Geni, home of the world's largest family tree.
Join Geni to explore your genealogy and family history in the World's Largest Family Tree.

Goldstein Family Research

« Back to Projects Dashboard

Project Tags

Top Surnames

view all

Profiles

  • Carolina Muenzer (1821 - 1857)
  • loeser Goldstein (1775 - d.)
    Source is from here: But I doubt all facts are accurate - because how could 2 brothers have exactly the same name? Maybe they were not brothers after all - just 2 people with the same name. -Mendy ...

The objective of this project is to figure out the first generation of The Goldstein family. There's some anonymous site (http://www.planet-rudolph.de/d0002/g0000029.htm#I513) that gives the following info:

Unknown Goldstein had 2 children:

   +Löser GOLDSTEIN
   +Loeser Eliezer Samuel GOLDSTEIN 

The Geni tree reflects this. For the sake of this discussion let's call the first Löser, Löser A, and the second Löser (our g-g-g-grandfather), Löser B.

I'm sure there is a mistake here because:

A) How could 2 brothers have the same name?

B) Löser B allegedly is the first one to adopt the name Goldstein (as stated in the Ulrich article), his original name being Smolenski. Did his brother Löser A have the same surname?

C) If Löser B's full name name is Eliezer Samuel - why did he give his son the name Samuel? (As we could see on the authentic family tree here: http://www.geni.com/photo/view/352945413380011038?photo_id=6000000013048575205

D) According to http://www.planet-rudolph.de/d0001/g0000070.htm#I475. Löser A, had a son Bernhard Goldstein, according to our tree Löser B had a son Bernhard Goldstein. Is it a coincidence?

E) According to http://www.planet-rudolph.de/d0001/g0000070.htm#I475, Löser A's son Bernhard married Caroline LAQUEUR. According to our tree Löser B's son Bernhard also married someone called Caroline LAQUEUR. A double coincidence?

Perhaps, the other brother is no brother at all - the guy who made the family tree just put them together my mistake. or the other brother's name was Samuel not Löser.