I am fully confident of the my part of Taylor line back to John R. Taylor (1861-1947). Union Francis Taylor was my grandfather, and his son, Joseph Robert ("Joe Bob") was my dad. His brothers Lyal and Samuel were my uncles. Before that, the line gets murky and heavily crowdsourced.
My grandmother Martha Elizabeth (Jones) Taylor authored "Shore Lines" for the Newburgh Register.
Key question as of this date:
1. I am certain of John R. Taylor, but is it "John Rubin" or "John Reuben"?
2. Who is John M. Taylor?
2a. Is John M's father really the Rev. Lewis Taylor of Yankeetown and Boonville? (Lewis is also the father of Gurley and Peter Taylor, among others)