Joe Biden has repeatedly claimed on camera that he is "Irish" Quote: I am Irish.
The press is writing: Biden's victory was celebrated in his ancestral home of Ireland as well
The Geni tree shows the Biden ancestors are entirely from England, not Ireland. Usually one regards an "ancestral homeland" as the paternal one. It is clearly not Irish unless the Geni tree is wrong.
On his mother's side he has some great-grandparents who were Irish.
Trump's father's family was Bavarian but he never claimed to be German. Neither did he claim to be Scottish, although his mother was Scottish.
Conclusion: Joe Biden is as Irish as Trump is Scottish. But please do check the supposed Biden Irish ancestry which is not apparent on the Geni tree- with the immigrant/emigrant Biden born in "England".
His mother's side looks pretty Irish to me.
https://www.geni.com/list/ancestors/6000000010061822254#6
Women exist, and we count. :) To be honest, I'm stunned that anyone would think an "ancestral homeland" or ethnic identity is based on paternal ancestry only. A handful of cultures are aggressively patrilineal (or outright misogynistic) like that, but they're rare. I'm sure I'm just misunderstanding you, of course.
His maternal grandfather's family was mostly from County Louth. His maternal grandmother's family was from County Mayo, mostly Ballina. That's showing in the tree, so I see no issues here.
"Biden's great-grandfather, James Finnegan, emigrated from County Louth as a child, in 1850. All eight of his great-great-grandparents on his mother's side was born in Ireland during, the first half of the 19th century. On his father's side, two great-grandparents were also born in Ireland. Essentially that makes him five-eighths Irish." https://www.irishcentral.com/news/politics/presidential-candidate-j...
See also https://medium.com/@smolenyak/joe-bidens-irish-roots-64135cc97fd7
I could've sworn I'd read at some point that he had ancestors from Gaoth Dobhair (Gweedore), County Donegal, but I can't find anything on that now. But that could be the paternal Irish ancestors, so I'll keep looking.
He's also somehow connected to Rob and Dvae Kearney, the great Irish rugby players, through his Finnegans, but I've yet to find the precise path.
John Albert Rigali, I had already removed the president-elect display name that was added by someone else -- not because I think it's wrong or likely to change, but because it's not official until the Electoral College votes. As soon as they vote, I'll add it back.
Let's keep this thread focused on his ethnic background, however.
It is *not* a political forum, Nana Jo Redell, and political comments risk being reported to Geni staff.
The question of this thread is about his ethnic background. From what we know, his background is majority Irish, with English and German as well.
What does it show on GENI right now ?
His ancestors from where ?
Roderick Hinkel says majority on GENI English.
My dna says 43 % Scandinavian most likely Norwegian yet have hardky any Scandinavian ancestors here on GENI. My paternal yDNA suggest most likeky proto-Germanic from Ukraine does that make me an ethnic German from Ukraine?
J P Weyers, I do not understand your comment. Can you explain?
Private User, although at this time it appears that VP Biden will win the electoral college vote, I think that Pres. Trump will win his law suit(s?) and ultimately take the win for himself. I do recognize that what results that we speculate are irrelevant to Geni- proper Geni procedure should be followed. Thanks for doing that.
As stated twice previously, we're not going to discuss politics here. If Phillipp wants to elaborate on his first comment, please do so through PM. If you'd like to discuss Biden's ethnic background, however, feel free to carry on.
Roderick, it looks like our English lines for Biden could use some additional sources. If you have the time and interest, please feel free to add them! Every little bit helps. Otherwise, we'll probably be waiting until the NEHGS releases the "official" genealogy in the spring.
Unfortunately, they're also somewhat hard to come by in Maryland, which is the U.S. state his father's ancestors largely came through from England.
One bit of hope for establishing the deeper English ties would be his most recent English-born Biden ancestor, William H. (Henry?) Biden. It appears there was a William Biden born on that date in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire, so if we could establish that they're the same person, we might be able to take that English line back a bit further. Looks like some genealogists in the area are working on that same idea: https://www.huntspost.co.uk/news/joe-biden-has-ancestors-in-hunting...
Does Biden want to be Irish ? Why ? Not something one can choose.
As Roderick has shown me , we can not pick our family .
Ancestors may be discovered often similar names and we go down the wrong path. Then new info is found and you on the right track ( maybe ) again.
One can not force fit a desired ancestor and edit out an infamous ancestor
J P Weyers Roche is apparently a common Irish surname. It is thought to have Norman origins hence why is sounds a bit French: https://ireland-calling.com/irish-names-roche-roach/
More sourcing would be great! We are always looking for help with that if you want to contribute!
See my notes on Catherine Finnegan's profile for the reasoning for the parents. I'll upload the sources that I mentioned to the profiles in question.
I see that you mention on Thomas Roche's profile: "Might be him. but his daughter Catherine married a Pat Rynne not Finnegan." What is your source for this marriage?
https://sv.findagrave.com/memorial/214541644/thomas-roche same as
Thomas Roche
here with a daugher Maria R. Roche burried at Ovid, Seneca County, New York, USA.
Catherine (Roche) Finnegan (abt. 1840 - abt. 1885)
Daughter of [father unknown] and [mother unknown] [sibling(s) unknown]
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Roche-514
Apology Tamas
For the sake of transparency sholud have added link to source not just write it in
-on familysearch Thoms Roche and Brudgey Fox children Catherine born 1849 ( not 1846 ? ) and Peter. Link to a marraige for Catherine Roche and Pat Rynne but do not believe was definitely right . Wiil find link to source and post here.
Could you add all link to sources for census 1841 and 1851 for Catherine Roche will strengthen her proof of parents for all to see .