John McFadden (McFaddien) - Problems with parents of John McFadden

Heard from one profile manager that Candor Adams McFadden needs to stay with the parents Robert and Margaret.

Any more info?

What I found on Robert Adams McFadden on https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/208701153/robert-adams-mcfadden

Robert Adams McFadden
BIRTH 1690
Antrim (County Antrim), County Antrim, Northern Ireland
DEATH 1740 (aged 49–50)
Antrim (County Antrim), County Antrim, Northern Ireland
BURIAL
Templecorran Graveyard
Ballycarry, County Antrim, Northern Ireland
MEMORIAL ID 208701153 · View Source
MEMORIAL
PHOTOS 0
FLOWERS 2
Robert Adam McFadden was born about 1690 in County Antrim, North Ireland.
He married about 1708 Margaret Elliot probably in County Antrim.

Known Children:
1. John Edward McFadden 1708 - 1773 Md Margaret Lemmon. Died Near Indian Town, Williamsburg, South Carolina. Buried: Sardina-Gable Cemetery, Sardinia, Claredon County, South Carolina.#91515779
2. Candor Adams McFadden 1710 - 1789 Md Mary Hannah Guy Buried Fishing Creek Church Cemetery, Chester, South Carolina #161725830
3. Robert McFadden 1730 - 1789 Died Chester County, South Carolina
4. William McFadden 1731 - 1792 Died Fairfield County, South Carolina
5. Edward McFadden 1740 - 1836 Md Jane Armstrong Rev War Soldier, Buried: Sargent Cemetery, Maury County, Tennessee. #144908463
6. James McFadden

Please note! Known children seem to be incomplete and some dates may be questionable. Would appreciate any corrections or additions or any other helpful information.

and on Margaret Elliott on https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/208715733/margaret-mcfadden

Margaret Elliot McFadden was born 3 December 1692 in Edinburgh Parish, Edinburgh , Midlothian, Scotland the daughter of Johne and Elizabeth Feithie Elliot.
She married about 1708 probably in County Antrim, Robert Adams McFadden of County Antrim, North Ireland.

Known Children:
1. John Edward McFadden 1708 - 1773 Md Margaret Lemmon. Died Near Indian Town, Williamsburg, South Carolina. Buried: Sardina-Gable Cemetery, Sardinia, Claredon County, South Carolina.#91515779
2. Candor Adams McFadden 1710 - 1789 Md Mary Hannah Guy Buried Fishing Creek Church Cemetery, Chester, South Carolina #161725830
3. Robert McFadden 1730 - 1789 Died Chester County, South Carolina
4. William McFadden 1731 - 1792 Died Fairfield County, South Carolina
5. Edward McFadden 1740 - 1836 Md Jane Armstrong Rev War Soldier, Buried: Sargent Cemetery, Maury County, Tennessee. #144908463
6. James McFadden

Please note! Known children seem to be incomplete and some dates may be questionable. Would appreciate any corrections or additions or any other helpful information.
____________________________________________

Some of the above does not compute I don't think in terms of dates and places, but more needed ?????

There seems some confusion with a Robert McFaydean who married Margaret Carson in Scotland and a Robert McFadden who married Margaret Eliot in Ireland. Dates are confused.

Needs more work.

url
https://www.myheritage.com/research/record-1-188952452-1-500776/rob...
Citation
My Heritage
Notes
Robert McFadden
Birth: Circa 1710 - Ireland
Death: 1740 - Antrim, Ireland
Wife: Margaret Mcfadden (born Elliot)
Children: John E. Mcfadden, Candour Mcfadden, Ii

"Isle of Man Parish Registers, 1598-2009," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:X8SP-883 : 2 March 2021), Robt Mcfadyean and Margt Carson, 16 Feb 1730, Marriage; citing German, Isle of Man, Manx National Heritage Library, Douglas.

*Name: Robt Mcfadyean
• Event Type: Marriage
*Event Date: 16 Feb 1730
• Event Place: German, Isle of Man
• Sex: Male
*Spouse's Name: Margt Carson
• Spouse's Sex: Female

Both of the above marriages were noted on the Family Search Profile of Robert Adams McFadden - https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/sources/LVQL-88Y

I am not convinced that Pvt. Edward McFadden, Sr., Rev. War Vet. is a son of Robert Adams McFadden and Margaret Eliot. Not finding anything.

Need to review that relationship also.

I've worked through trying to clean up Isaac McFadden, Sr. son of Candour Adams McFadden and Mary Guy Isaac was another Revolutionary War patriot. There were lots of merges and clean ups. Please review what has taken place to see what is needed or if it is correct. No disconnections, just clean up so far. Need more info such as wills, etc. if available.

Still unsure if Candor is with parents Robert McFadden and Margaret, but the key may be which set of Roberts and Margarets.

From https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/161725830/candor-adams-mcfadden

The Find a Grave memorial is a mish mash of information about Candor the Imigrant and younger generations. No note of his parents in the narrative, but it does not have him connected to Robert Adams McFadden and Margaret Elliot.

More research is needed to make connection with current parents.

The saga of the McFaddens of SC is still going on. This time, the wives and children of John.

According to various sources, John Edward McFadden had two wives:

Margaret McFaddien who had with him the following American Revolutionary War patriot sons:

John McFaddin

Thomas McFaddin

Robert McFadden

After Margaret Lemmon's death, John married Margaret McFadden Children with Margaret Price noted in his will probated on July 13, 1773:

James McFaddin date of birth June 6, 1773.

Mary McFaddin who had to be born before 1773 as she and James are both named in the will.

Then there is William McFaddin who Find a Grave has him born on December 24, 1773 and I suspect that is the tombstone birthdate.

Here is the issue or is it? We are saying that a woman delivered a child in June, her husband died in July and she had another child by him in December? In the 1770s? William is not named in the will of John, but Find a Grave links the family together.

It is believed that Margaret Price married three times. Any thoughts on this? I am posting the handwritten will off of ancestry. It starts on the right of page 1.

Additional notes on this profile at the bottom. I am fine with leaving William, but if we go by wills, he doesn't fit. However, his father may know have known of his existence. Is there any protocol for this situation.