Rabbi Avraham Ben Yekhiel Luria, Gaon of Egypt - Any sources for Rabbi Avraham Ben Yekhiel Luria, Gaon of Egypt?

Started by Private User on Monday, April 25, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Showing all 5 posts

There are currently two fathers listed for Rabbi Avraham Ben Yekhiel, Gaon of Egypt

One is an obviously fake tree from Jaim.

The other appears to be plausible, but has some grafted on profiles further up the chain from Jaim.

Could be an easy fix: i.e. cut the completely fake parent profile here, and then look into the parents of Joseph ben Yakob haKohen Bar Saṭya, ABD, Gaon of Sura after.

cc Randy Schoenberg

Private User

It is not about two different fathers, This is about the same father,that someone established a tree parallel to the general tree .... The problem is in the continuation of the tree (backwards), the same person who established the parallel tree connected the branch to different ancestors than the tree established by Jaim David HARLOW

Haim Katz - Hachoen Wartski Jaim's tree is not correct though, so we can solve a lot of problems by just disconnecting the incorrect tree here, and then working on the better tree.

O.K.

The origin of all of this is a book called Tiferet Beit David (Jerusalem, 1968) by Rabbi Moshe Yair Weinstock which traces the ancestry of the Maharal of Prague to Rabbi Sherira Gaon. The legitimacy of Weinstock's work is somewhat in question.

Showing all 5 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion