Ann has two same-name husbands connected. They're not the same man, having different parents. Ancestry only shows her married to the one whose parents are Joseph and Betty (Clark) Anthony:
Father
Joseph Anthony (1713–1785)
Mother
Elizabeth Ann Betty Clark (1720–1822)
Spouse
Nancy Ann Tate (1752–1834)
Is there documentation proving conclusively which James Anthony was her husband?
Thanks in advance for any documentation / clarification.