Frederick James Preston - Alt data

I'm resolving the data after a merge Will, so you tell me which it should be- I think Smithfield, Westmorland, Jamaica

Frederick James Preston b 1844 Jamaica & sister Bessie Preston b 1855 (England??) show impossible father Alfred William Preston b 1889 & Elizabeth Wells McDonald b 1820 Jamaica

Most recent merge
https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=83483403210

Should that merge be undone?

You mean because of the dates?
I've got to unmerge to see the other one it seems - let's see what it was:

Alfred William Preston
Alfred William Preston
Gender: Male
Birth: estimated between 1839 and 1839
Salesbury, Lancashire
Immediate Family:
Son of Charles Preston and Jane Elizabeth Tunnard
Father of Frederick James Preston and Bessie Preston
Brother of John Preston and Alice Preston

Added by: Edward Alfred Leo Preston on 7 July 2007
Managed by: Edward Alfred Leo Preston and Dr. Wilton McDonald II - Attorney & Barrister

Here's the original merge - dates still out
https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=79278887680

Looks like I've got to undo that too to see it as a profile outside of the merge record
Alfred William Preston
Alfred William Preston
Gender: Male
Birth: estimated between 1790 and 1838
Salesbury, Lancashire
Immediate Family:
Father of Frederick James Preston and Bessie Preston
Added by: Edward Alfred Leo Preston on 7 July 2007
Managed by: Edward Alfred Leo Preston

merged into
Alfred William Preston
Alfred William Preston
Gender: Male
Birth: estimated between 1833 and 1833
Salesbury, Lancashire
Immediate Family:
Son of Charles Preston and Jane Elizabeth Tunnard
Father of John P Freestone; Adam Freestone; Albert Freestone; Lydia Freestone; Edward Freestone; Bessie Preston and Samuel Freestone « less
Brother of John Preston and Alice Preston
Added by: Dr. Wilton McDonald II - Attorney & Barrister on 29 November 2020
Managed by: Dr. Wilton McDonald II - Attorney & Barrister

These matched English trees do not go to Jamaica (or Louisiana)

https://www.myheritage.com/profile-251383621-1000046/alfred-william...

https://www.myheritage.com/profile-499868821-1500156/alfred-william...

Deleting incorrectly confirmed source - actually for this man: William Preston by Wilton.

Deleting dates and place for birth circa 1889 Salesbury, Lancashire
and for death Death: circa 1932 (34-51)
, pending the provision of primary / secondary Sources

Sharon Doubell - i think you can remerge now and match the original profile entry. Conflict triangle at Frederick James Preston

Private User hasn't been on Geni since 2017, and provides no primary sources for the 1889 Salesbury, Lancashire birth.

I can't ethically resolve the Frederick triangle, without knowing if these are the same people, so I've removed the Salesbury Alfred - but I think this is a definite avenue to pursue for primary records in Lancashire.

Bessie Preston also has no sources and wasn't originally added by Edward Alfred Leo Preston, whose profile the Salesbury Alfred was -

She also doesn't appear here - our source for the rest of her Jamaica family:

Generation No. 2
3. Elizabeth [2 Jamaica Law 6 Burial Register I, 1871-1874, I, p. 13 #616.] McDonald (James [1 Jamaica Parish Register Marriage III & IV, 1838-1855, III, p. 68 #26.] ) was born Bet. 1819 - 1820. She married Alfred William Preston August 16, 1843 in Hanover [7Jamaica Parish Register Marriage III & IV, 1838-1855, III, p. 107 #59.]
.
More About Elizabeth McDonald:

• Age: 1823, 3 years on Hanover census
• Race/nationality/color: Mustee
• Residence: Bet. 1823 - 1843, Hanover

More About Alfred William Preston:

• Residence: 1843, Westmoreland

More About Alfred Preston and Elizabeth McDonald:

• Ceremony by: H. G. Lawson, Island Curate
• Marriage: August 16, 1843, Hanover7
• Marriage license: 1843

Child of Elizabeth McDonald and Alfred Preston is:

• + 7 i. Frederick James3 Preston, born Bet. 1843 - 1844; died August 31, 1880 in Smithfield, Westmoreland.

Jamaican Family Search Genealogy Research Library Descendants of Briggs, D'Aguilar, Lindo, McDonald, Philibert and Pouyat

Instead, she's 10 years and a different place away from her brother's birth. I've asked for primary sources to link her back to them.