Jean le Roux, SV/PROG 3 - DNA Y G-M201 added to Jean le Roux,S/V Prog 3

6/6/2023 at 6:44 AM

The only note to this DNA is :"I am now G-P287 "There seems to be confussion.Also the tree does not trace back to the Private doner.
Source info and reason for adding are required please help.

Sonja Kantey

6/6/2023 at 10:35 AM

This profile was merged with other users. So, I am not sure who added what.
I have now gained access for the first time and will fix what I can fix from my side.
Regards

Fanie Jacobs, b2c11d2e11f3g1

6/7/2023 at 5:47 AM

Sonja,thanks for the help.I have established that the doner himself posted on Fam search{LDS} and on his version of his tree,he is connected to the other Jean..Apparently there are two other tests ,relating to our Jean--Both Big 7.Any knowledge of such tests?

Sonja Kantey

6/8/2023 at 11:55 PM

To tell you the truth - I am only sure that my facts are straight up to about my great grandfather.

With all the merging and being unable to delete - it appears to be a fine mess.

To answer your question - I haven't really looked at these things for a few years, so, I am not aware of any tests.

Fanie Jacobs, b2c11d2e11f3g1

6/9/2023 at 4:41 AM

Sonja Kantley-thanks for the possible inaccuracy after your great grand father.. I had asimilar problem where mt findings differed from the accepted..Now curious to see if DNA match..There is a lot of conflicting and "private" info in the mid 1800's with the le Roux and associated families. Pardon my "is and are's'-ek is Afrikaans.
Lets hope time will tell

Sharon Doubell C

6/9/2023 at 7:24 AM

Gideon Hendrik Niemann le Roux seems to be source of the Y DNA that propagated to Jean.

Sharon Doubell C

6/9/2023 at 7:31 AM

Jean le Roux, SV/PROG 3
his father → Pierre le Roux
his father → Pierre le Roux
his brother → Jean le Roux, SV/PROG 1
his son → Pierre 'Pieter' Janszoon le Rosis / le Rioue / le Roux, b2
his son → Jan le Roux, b2c1
his son → Johannes Gerhardus Le Roux, a1b2c1d4
his son → Abel Jacobus Francois le Roux
his son → Petrus Johannes Le Roux
his son → Petrus Johannes le Roux
his son → Cornelius Willem le Roux
his son → Gideon Hendrik Niemann le Roux
his son

connection relies on the link between Jean le Roux and Jean le Roux being valid.

Sharon Doubell C

6/9/2023 at 8:07 AM

There seems to be no source validity that backs up a Pierre le Roux as the brother of Pierre le Roux It seems unlikely. Disconnecting the former, pending sources.

Sharon Doubell C

6/9/2023 at 8:08 AM

And we lose the DNA propagation. Pity, but rather have a valid and proved link.

Jean le Roux, SV/PROG 3 - DNA Y G-M201 added to Jean le Roux,S/V Prog 3

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion