Chana Golda Tabak (Aronovits) - Chana Golda Farkas and Chana Tabak

Started by Yaakov Moshe Schatz on Monday, July 10, 2023
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 8 posts

Chana Golda Farkas had children 1858-1867.
Chana Tabak had children 1853-1863.
I therefore do not see how they could be the same person. Could you explain why you think they are the same person?

Furthermore, Chana Golda Altman born 1888 would not have been given that name if her grandmother was still alive. Chana Tabak, in contrast, was alive until 1903.

According to my research, Chana Golda Aronovics was rhe daughter of Aron and Dvojra Aronovics. She first married Tobias Farkas and then married Szender Tabak. The problem with record’s website such as JewishGen is that you can never rely on the dates their. I already found different records of the same person that say a different date of birth. Is there more reliable information that shows that they are different people?

Who is Chana Altman?

Are you certain that they are two different people?

I looked at the records I collected and I have good reason to believe that this is the same woman

Can l send you the records so you be able to examine them?

I think we have to look more and see if we have the correct birth dates for all of the children. If she was married twice, to Tabak and then Farkas, the Tabak kids should all come first followed by Farkas kids. She also would have death records and burial as Chana Farkas, not Tabak.

Yes. Please send me the documents and if possible an explanation as to why you think they are the same person.

my email is: YaakovSchatz@gmail.com

When we have all the details in front of us we can think together of the alternatvie explanations to the details and make a decision as to what is most probable.

Thanks,

Yaakov

Showing all 8 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion