Doba (Solnitsky) Shiller

Private User

8/1/2023 at 11:57 AM

This profile - Doba Shiller - is currently listed as Doba (Solnitsky) Shiller with Immediate Family:
Biological daughter of Israel Solnitzky and Freda (Gumbiner) Solnitzky
Adopted daughter of Israel Solnitsky and Devorah (Gumbiner) Solnitzky
Wife of Benjamin Shiller

The two Israels are separate profiles.

Randy Schoenberg
Steven Isaac Shewach
Steven Shiller
Is this a case where it is actually known she was born to one couple and adopted by another --
Or where records are unclear, and you do not want to smush together two couples who may not be the same,
but if they are different,
you cannot determine which records for her go with the daughter of each
(ie cannot tell how or if should split her)

Private User

8/3/2023 at 12:28 PM

I have heard from one of Doba's great grandchildren, who says

"I am Doba's great grandson.

According to my father, Doba's mother died shortly after child birth. I am not sure if it was Doba's birth or another sibling that did not survive.

Anyway, after her mother's passing, her father Israel married his wife's sister."

So i am thinking
1) we should merge the Israel who is bio dad and the Israel who is her adoptive dad.

And
2) we should merge the profiles currently shown as her bio mom, nee Freda Gumbiner, and her adoptive mom's sister listed currently as Fraydah Sarah (Gumbiner) Solnitski

Please let me know if there are any objections.

Private User

8/6/2023 at 7:42 PM

Having heard no objections, I have now merged them.

Log in using Email

Doba (Solnitsky) Shiller - Parents

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion