There are documents on Ancestry that list this Henry and his wife as the parents of daughter Mahala as connected here on Geni BUT have his parents named as James Reynolds and Sarah Lindsay. It also says he was born in VA, moved to KY and then to TN and finally settled in Indiana.
I don't know if the info on Ancestry is correct or the info here on Geni or if some same-name folks' info has gotten crossed up. Just sharing what is on the other site. I'll add the documents under his Media tab for everyone's review.