Rosalia Römer (Wind) - On the birth surname and parentage of Rosalia Römer

When I posted the message of 28 Jan 2024 that begins this thread, there was one highly relevant fact of which I was ignorant, namely that a daughter named Rosalia was already attributed Jonas and Judith Rind, namely Rosalia Stein (1818–1877). The latter is clearly a distinct person from the Rosalia who married Hermann Römer. I believe her to be the "Rosalia" in the birth record that I mentioned in paragraph (5) of my message.

"Rosalia" being such a popular name in Czechia in this time period, and the records being so slack about women's names, it could certainly happen that the name "Rosalia" was, on one occasion or another, attributed to two sisters. But it is extremely unlikely that each of the two would appear *consistently* with just that name and no other, as is the case here. So the fact that Jonas and Judith Rind have an entirely distinct daughter named "Rosalia" argues strongly against the identification of the present Rosalia as their daughter.

Of the other four points in my former argument, all of them seem to me still correct and relevant, and all of them still seem to me to support, indeed collectively to dictate, the conclusion that the Rosalia who married Hermann Römer was named "Rind" and not "Wind." The question is: of which Rind male was she the daughter?

There was a hypothesis that I mentioned in my fourth paragraph, only to dismiss it as "conflicting with the available data" and "having no positive support," namely that the name "Moises Wind" in Rosalia's marriage record is an erroneous reference to Michael Rind whose wife, like the mother mentioned in the marriage record of Rosalia, was named "Henriette." The lack of positive support remains, but I would point out that the conflict of this hypothesis with the data is confined to the given name attributed to Rosalia's father—"Moises" instead of "Michael." This is a quite modest conflict.

The marriage of Michael Rind and Henriette Wind is recorded on 8 Feb 1814; the birth of their first child, Moses Rind (my twice-great-grandfather), on 18 Oct 1815; the next recorded birth of a child to them after that is that of Samuel Rind on 17 Nov 1818. The birth of a child between the marriage and the birth of Moses—say, in December of 1815—is physically possible, but just barely. A birth between Moses and Samuel is far more likely.

In any case, I have concluded that Rosalia must have been a daughter of Michael (erroneously called "Moises" in the marriage record) and Henriette Rind, and have changed the relations of the profile accordingly.