Elijah Webb - Incorrect merge

Can you explain how they are incorrect? Looking at the merge revision it appears to be an exact match.

I do have a image of Elijah Webb who was my 3xgt uncle and brother of my 3xgt grandmother Matilda Webb/Furley.
I cannot see the discussed image to comment or verify.
.
My copy was given to me by Vera Wilson which was a copy from a newspaper.

Quite willing to share.
Regards.
Elaine nee Wilson