I cannot find a Plymouth, Rhode Island, which is what the birthplace shows.
According to Meredith Colket, John's father arrived at Plymouth Colony in 1643—if Colket's date is correct.
From Wikitree, John was born in Plymouth Colony:
"C[irca]. 1647 he married Deborah Jordan in Plymouth Colony where some of their children were born. By 1669, they resided in Quidnesset, part of what became North Kingstown Twp., Rhode Island. — https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Reynolds-221