Same person or not?

Started by Jacob Michael Gryn on Monday, November 22, 2010


Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 4 posts
11/22/2010 at 9:40 PM

Izrael Rozenblat is listed to have died in 1840, and Izrael Rosenblum does not have a death year listed. Also, the birthdate of 1797 vs c.1816

The names and dates of some of the children are identical. This makes me wonder. Are these 2 different people, or where is the error?

It seems the main sources of this info would be the profile managers Linda Sue Silverman Gidi Poraz, Private User and Gabriela Grausam. Maybe the sources can be re-checked for both these profiles, as there is definitely an error somewhere, either (if they are the same person) in the birth and death years, or (if they are different people) in the names of the children.

11/24/2010 at 4:07 AM

Izrael Rozenblum and Izrael Rozenblat are two separate people although they were both married to Golda Zaydner :-)

Izrael Rozenblat and Golda Zaydner were married 16 Jul 1831 in Olkusz..
Izrael Rozenblum and Golda Zaydner were married 16 Nov 1841 in Olkusz.

Izrael Rozenblat was the son of Moshe and Rosa.
Izrael Rozenblum was the son of Szmul and Sara Bayla.

Izrael Rozenblat was married to Haia Fraidla Zaydner who died in 1831 in Olkusz.

Believe me, it was torture figuring this whole thing out. I do believe I have it correct, but if someone can show me otherwise, please do!

11/24/2010 at 9:59 AM

So we need to sort out why some of the children are listed under both profiles? A simple start would be to remove any 1841 and up births from Rozenblat.

The question is how did they end up under both?

11/27/2010 at 5:04 PM

I think I need to cc: Gabriela Grausam on this conversation.

It would seem that everyone born post 1840 is a child of Rozenblum, pre would be a child of Rozenblat. The profiles apparently in error are managed by Gabriela Grausam.

May as well attach Golda Rozenblat Rosenblum to the discussion.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion