Andrew Toothacher

Is your surname Toothacher?

Research the Toothacher family

Andrew Toothacher's Geni Profile

Share your family tree and photos with the people you know and love

  • Build your family tree online
  • Share photos and videos
  • Smart Matching™ technology
  • Free!


Andrew Toothacher (Toothaker)

Birthdate: (81)
Birthplace: Billerica, Middlesex, MA
Death: 1760 (80)
Harpswell, Cumberland, Maine
Immediate Family:

Son of Dr. Roger Toothaker, Salem Witch Trials and Mary Toothaker (Allen), Salem Witch Trials
Husband of Abigail Toothaker
Father of Abigail Toothacher; Mehitable Grover; Elizabeth Allen; Seth Toothaker; Ebenezer Toothaker and 2 others
Brother of Nathaniel Toothacher; Martha Emerson; Allin Toothacher; Dr. Roger Toothaker; Sarah Whitaker and 2 others

Managed by: Private User
Last Updated:

About Andrew Toothacher

Note : NEH &G register Vol. 109 page 304 Andrew and wife Abigail left Massachusetts and settled in Maine. From LDS IGI F# 2034364, 458375 Andrew purchased 30 acres of land from a widow on 4 Dec 1713 in York, Maine and leased Frost land in 1719. In 1722 sold various town grants in connection with Wife Abigail July 1707. About 1735-1737 Andrew and his children moved

to Harpswell, Cumberland, Maine. Andrew Toothaker is listed as an owner of land there on Merriconcag Neck in 1737. Benjamin and Mehitable Grover moved on to Georgetown, Maine Elisha Allen and Job Moulton were residents of Harpswell Neck, Maine in 1740 as were Seth and Ebenezer Toothaker. ***See The History fo Brunswick, Topshan and Harpswell, Maine.*** Andrew married Abigail WHITE ? on 1707 in York, York, Maine. Abigail was born about 1680 in probably York, Maine. Her name is probably Abigail White. This last name is not for certain.

Other possible info:

Andrew Toothaker

Birth:   4 Oct 1679 
 Billerica, Massachusetts  
Death:   5 Aug 1695 
 Harpswell, Cumberland, Maine USA

Andrew Toothaker was born 4 October 1679 in Billerica, the fourth son of Roger and Mary (Allin) Toothaker. He married about 1707 to Abigail __. Andrew was at York, Maine as early as 1713, then to Harpswell with sons Seth and Ebenezer as early as 1737. Andrew died in 1760 at Harpswell, Maine.


Abigail b. 1707

Mehitable b. 13 Mar 1707/1708 in York, Maine, d. about 1795 in Georgetown, Maine. Found to be non compos mentis (mentally ill) Mehitable married Benjamin Grover on 27 Apr 1731 in York, Maine. Benjamin was born 12 Nov 1712 in York, Maine. Benjamin lived in York at least until 1741. Five of his children's births are listed in the York Town Vital Record Book. Mary, the eldest, has a # in front of her name, indicating she was deceased at the time of the enumeration. 1742-1745, Benjamin moved to North Yarmouth (Harpswell). The suggestion has been made that he went with the Toothakers, his wife's family. The Toothakers are known to have settled in Harpswell at about that time. Benjamin didn't stay long in Harpswell. He seems to have moved to Parker's Island, Georgetown, by 1748. No death record has been found for Benjamin. He's noted as deceased in the probate of his father, Andrew's, estate in May 1754.

Elizabeth b. 28 Jul 1710 in York, Maine, m. Elisha Allen. Elisha b. about 18 Jun 1709.

Seth b. 5 March 1714/1715 York, Maine

Ebenezer b. 3 January 1717/1718 York, Maine

(Poss) Margaret b. 3 Jan 1720/1721.

Mary b. 5 September 1722 York, Maine, m. (1) Job Moulton 20 Sep 1740. m. (2) Benjamin Denslow 6 Aug 1747 in Yarmouth, Maine

view all

Andrew Toothacher's Timeline

October 4, 1679
Billerica, Middlesex, MA
Age 27
March 13, 1708
Age 28
York, York Co., ME
July 28, 1710
Age 30
York, York County, Maine, United States
March 5, 1714
Age 34
York, ME, USA
January 3, 1717
Age 37
Harpswell, York County, Province of Massachusetts
January 3, 1721
Age 41
Age 42
Age 80
Harpswell, Cumberland, Maine