David Walker - What is the rule on GENI.com for crazy DNA surfers who keep merging and attaching strange DNA and wrong lineages?

When do we look at Fin-a-grave as a source?

Find-a-grave for this family has been completely messed up, I've given up trying to clean them up. As soon as I circle again they are linked wrong again.

Do I understand this correctly?

In my opinion

David married [Mary Walker Mary Walker] in 1718 in Goochland, Virginia, United States. Together they had the following children:

# [Peter Walker John Walker];
# [Peter Walker Peter Walker];
# [Joel Walker Joel Walker];
# [Elizabeth Thornhill Elizabeth Walker]; Thornhill
# [Mary Walker Mary Perkins];
# [Judith Poore Judith Walker]; Poore
# [Hope Lancaster Hope Lancaster (Walker)];
# [Amy Ann Pettus Amey Ann Pettus]; ? ck she should've been married to a Stevens ?
# [David Alexander Walker David Alexander Walker]; underage at father's death.
----
----
An in my opinion, the profiles listed below are connected to the wrong set of parents and should be disconnected -

These are extra children added to this profile - they don't belong - wrong David Walker and Mary

# [Captain Robert Walker, Sr. Robert Walker, Sr]; Not on Will
# [Freeman Walker Freeman Walker]; Not on Will
# [Susannah Walker Susannah Walker]; Not on will
# [Alexander Walker Alexander Walker]; Not on Will
# [Linder Walker Linder Walker]; Not on Will
# [William Andrew Walker William Walker]; Not on Will
# [James Walker James Walker]; Not on Will
# [Henry Walker Henry Walker]. Not on Will

Who was the other Mary?

I came across a discussion about the Two Wills of our Two David Walker's

This may assist us, I'm still searching for the complete original probated Will for David Walker and Mary Mumford Walker, I've never favored transcribed ones they can have mistakes, like leaving out names.

My shortest line to Amy Ann Pettus (Walker), who is my fifth great uncle's great-grandmother. (In-Law Line)

Aaron Furtado Baldwin → Ronnie Eugene Buchanan Baldwin your father → William Henry Buchanan his father → William Earl Buchanan his father → John Neal Buchanan his father → William Buchanan his father → Sarah "Sallie" Buchanan (Yarbrough) his mother → Susan Alice Brown (Yarbrough) her sister → Jesse Brown, Sr. her husband → William A. Brown his father → Mary Susan Brown (Pettus) his mother → Amy Ann Pettus (Walker) her mother

Colonel Thomas Branch Brown and Burgess Thomas Pettus are both qualifying ancestors for DAR/SAR and their ancestors Christopher Branch and Colonel Thomas Pettus are both qualifying ancestors for The Jamestowne Society ... so I locked of these lines is probably needed

I personally have a lot of Brown/Branch family information ... some Pettus and no real Walker family information.

Erica to the recuse!

Aaron

However, Amy's daughter Ann Eggleston (Pettus) did carry the Overton family name ... Ann Overton Eggleston (Pettus) and she married Joseph Eggleston (1678-1730). So, while untangling someone may want to add that.

Amy's granddaughter, Amy Childs Winstead (Brown), was the second wife of my 6th great -grandfather Mandley Taylor Winstead, Sr. of Hopkins County, Kentucky. She was the daughter Col. Thomas Branch Brown and Mary Susan Brown (Pettus)

Mandley Taylor Winstead, Sr.

Not sure if this helps, but these are long-term allied families, at least 5-7 generations