
PTID:6000000188814283824:6000000187259281853 allegedly died in 1859
Finch Shiplet, Jr was born in 1861
These dates don't work with basic math, so either one of the dates or both is wrong, or they are not parent/child.
In both the 1860 and 1870 US census PTID:6000000188864230829:6000000187259589823 is listed with a child named Finch, born c1859/1860.
Lucretia is a widow at this time.
If PTID:6000000188864230831:6000000187259281853 did die 1 September 1859 then he is quite probably the father of Finch Shiplet, Jr
The note in FAG "Louetta (Hardaway) Shiplet: she speculates this is Finch Shiplet,II to be a son of William M. and Lucretia (Reynolds) Shiplet" seems unlikely given that Lucretia was William's stepmother.