This is about Inconsistency and Source conflict. Well on my part there is no inconsistency. My Great Grandfather Henry like just about all of his family. were born in Richmond Victoria Australia. But try as you might to put that in, on your enter page is these pop up places and when you put Richmond Victoria Australia. It comes up with Richmond City of Yarra Victoria Australia or it brings up Richmond with a post Code. You should remove all of these things from the Entry page. For instance Not all People born in England, Scotland, Ireland or Wales, were born in the United Kingdom, this title did not come into being till much later. Also Some people born in Victoria, Australia, in the early times come under the Colony of New South Wales, Australia. Also on death Certificates places of death are plainly listed and you should be able to put what is listed on it as place of Death, that includes house No, or Hospital, or Nursing home. You should also be able to put place of Burial, which is the Cemetery they are buried in, this is clearly listed on the death Certificate. The Address of the Cemetery is not there place of Burial, and people look for a cemetery, not an address. These restrictions you have on here, show that this was set up by a person that knows nothing about Genealogy. I have been a Genealogist since 1979, I worked with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints between 1997 and 2017 in their Heidelberg Stake Genealogical Library, and I am an Online Parish Clerk for a Parish of St Michael, Haselbury Plucknett, Somerset, England .
Also while I have your attention, could you please tell me why? when you go to the remove button on someone, because they have been added to your page, and they are not your relation, not connected in any shape or form. The thing comes up you cannot remove as this will split the tree. Well if the thing aloud you to remove people who are not relations of yours, it would make it a lot easier for eveyone. I know who I am related too. I have one side of my family back to 970 and the other to as far back as the Queen can go, as I am related to the Royals in 5 ways. Well I for one am sick of people breaking the first rule of Genealogy, which is "You cannot pick a Family and slot yourself into it," it just does not work, you have to research and obtain Certificates. I had not been on Geni for a long time as I was looking after a sick husband and when he recovered, our daughter was struck down with an unknown illness, which she is still suffering from. My husband's Nephew Simon Mensfourth invited me to grow the tree on Geni. When I added my Great Great Grandparents William Sharp and his wife Mary Ann Sibley I could not add the details as your popups again stopped that. My daughter was struck with another illness, so I did not continue, with adding people. The day before yesterday I discovered that other people have been added to my Mary Ann Sibley also she had been stated to have been born in a place she was not. I removed these places and put her correct place. I used the proper things to try and remove the people that was added, by a Janet Hayes, who somehow is also listed on my page when she is not connected to me. I sent her a message. Yesterday I went to Mary Ann Sibley, and all these people above her are now blank. But because they are there I cannot add Mary Ann Sibley's real parents to her which are William Robert Sibley and Ann Hales. There is also an Elizabeth Ward married to a Thomas Trenaman listed as the daughter of my Alfred Samuel Ward and his wife Julia Rendell, They never had a daughter Elizabeth and Alfred did not have a sister Elizabeth. David Prins merged this into my tree, on 19 Jan 2023, when I contacted him about it. He said he did not do it, but I received an Email from Geni stating he did. Now this is another person attached to my family that I cannot remove. This is rediculous how do you expect people to do their family history, when you allow anyone like David Prins who said he merged it to see what was different. Then just leaves it there and does nothing. Before they merge anything with your tree, they should make contact with you. You should also tell him, that my tree is my tree, they are my ancestors I do know who they are. Regards Margaret Grace Silva
