Leib Aryeh Rozner (Rosner) - Leib Aryeh Rosner - I have not received any proof of his connection to Perla (Paula) Hutschnecker

Hi,
We are DNA cousins. I am Autosomal at-DNA cousin with more than five profiles on Geni that match perfectly with this connection. I am also Mitochondrial mt-DNA cousin you and with a descendant of the brother you mention on your message, that match perfectly with this connection. In addition to this, the burial location you describe on Geni in Hebrew is also a perfect match with this connection. Perla (Paula) Hutschnecker (Rosner/ Rozner) was my great grandmother. She left Ukraine where her family was all buried, crossed the border to Romania, and she never returned to her homeland for the obvious reasons.
Therefore, for now I am perfectly happy with this connection.
Andrei Elian

Hi.
Mitochondrial DNA is not relevant. Mitochondrial DNA is only passed on from the mother. Since the tested descendants of Leib Aryeh Rozner are through his son, mitochondrial DNA has no significance.
Autosomal DNA is also not evidence, because Ashkenazi DNA may be close in several different directions. What's more, according to the connection you mentioned, the connection seems to be in the direction of the Shafer family, and not in the direction of the Rosner family.
Only Y-DNA can possibly verify such a relationship.
Anyway, I was going to say that I have not received any traditional genealogical evidence such as records, that show this hypothetical connection.
Therefore, for now, I completely reject this theoretical connection.
Dr. Simcha Gershon Bohrer

Hi again, thank you for this.
In my opinion, if the scientific DNA test results on Geni and ordinary human common sense don’t satisfy you for now, I could then suggest… you just wait a while, I believe there is not very long to wait for the AI on Geni… This technology is already widely available here in UK…
Therefore, for now I am just perfectly happy with what I’ve got here on Geni.
Andrei Elian