Thomas Holcombe - Burial Place or Memorial?

Started by Private User on yesterday
Showing all 3 posts
Private User
yesterday at 10:13 PM

Wikitree, once it settles down from ranting paragraphs, finally adds useful matter for consideration:
"The FamilySearch card showing Abigail Holcombe born in Granby[8] is derived from a large tombstone erected in Granby by descendants of Thomas Holcombe. The many errors on it have been propagated over time and multiplied over the Internet. See Genealogical Vandalism - Thomas Holcombe's Tombstone, by George McCracken, in The American Genealogist Vol. 44, p. 58, January 1968, for details. McCracken, F.A.S.G., F.G.S.P., also documents Holcombe descendants in TAG Vol. 57." https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Holcomb-847

https://connecticuthistory.org/towns-page/granby/ states: "Granby...was settled in 1660 and incorporated in 1786 from a section of Simsbury."
The author cites sources that conflict with the 1660 timing. Two books play it safe and refer to Granby when it became "incorporated. The third book takes a completely different approach:—
1. – Salmon Brook Historical Society, and Mark Williams. A Tempest in a Small Town: The Myth and Reality of Country Life: Granby, Connecticut, 1680-1940. Granby, CT: Salmon Brook Historical Society, 1996.
2. – Granby Bicentennial Committee. Granby, Connecticut: A Brief History, 1786-1986. Granby, CT: Granby Bicentennial Committee, 1986.
3. – Phelps, Noah A. History of Simsbury, Granby and Canton from 1642 to 1845. Hartford, CT: Case, Tiffany and Burnham, 1845. – NOTE: A chapter title reads: "Granby. – Settlement. Civil and Ecclesiastical History. 1681–1845". https://archive.org/details/historyofsimsbur00phel/page/n3/mode/2up...
4. – Salmon Brook Historical Society. The Heritage of Granby, 1786-1965: Its Founding and History. Granby, CT: Salmon Brook Historical Society, 1967.

Today at 6:44 AM

Hi Ken,
The Holcombe line begins in Windsor. Granby and Simsbury were once part of Windsor. There is still currently a farm under the family name of Holcombe in Granby. I will look at my records to see what I have , and will check with the Windsor Historical Society as I live in town and it is close to me. I was recently going to go to that farm then I got ill. Planning to go soon.

Private User
Today at 4:46 PM

Hi, Patricia. I moved to Granby since 2005. I just came upon Wikitree's commentary. The complete chapter about Granby in the Phelps book is really as close as one ever had on the history of the time. Wikipedia pages about cities and towns usually control or revise authorship about their towns. However, there's no attempt to utilize the broader content from this book it cites as a source.
The link to the Granby chapter: https://archive.org/details/historyofsimsbur00phel/page/103/mode/1u...

The area may've named Granby before it was sufficiently inhabited as a "settlement". Just when that was may not be known. After reading the Phelps chapter, it seems possible the naming of northern "Simsbury" as Granby occurred as early as 1660?

Showing all 3 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion