Y-DNA

Started by Robin Rockey Mackey on Saturday, December 24, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 8 posts

Why are there no Y-DNA matches to mine? I find it hard to believe.

None on Geni, or also none on FTDNA?

Check your Profile Privacy Settings
☑ Allow other users to match my DNA results
☑ Propagate my DNA results to other profiles in my family tree
☑ Allow my relatives' DNA results to be propagated to my profile

Lois and Bjorn,
For example, when I type in: Elias Mackey *site: geni.com (Elias is my 5th great grandfather confirmed.), I get this as a result:

Elias Mackay is your 11th cousin thrice removed.

You
 

Leoma Johnson
your mother

Lila Aquilla Wilson
her mother

William John "Polecat" Wilson
her father

Bartlet J. Wilson
his father

Joshua Gregory Wilson
his father

Frances Wilson
his mother

William Ballard, Jr.
her father

Philadelphia Ballard
his mother

Mary Lea
her mother

Elizabeth Greene
her mother

Abraham Iverson
her father

Catherine Wallace
his mother

Adam Wallace
her father

Sir John Wallace of Craigie, 7th of Craigie, 12th of Riccarton
his father

Margaret de Dunbar, Countess of Crawford
his mother

David Lindsay, 5th Earl of Crawford, 1st Duke of Montrose
her son

Elizabeth Lindsay
his daughter

Isobell Gordon of Lochinvar
her daughter

Janet Mckie
her daughter

Patrick Mckie, Burgess of Wigtown
her son

Alexander Mckie, Laird of Larg
his son

Sir Patrick M’Kie, M.P. for the stewartry of Kirkcudbright
his son

Grizel M'kie
his daughter

Alexander McKee (M'Kie)
her son

William Mackey
his son

Alexander Mackey, Sr.
his son

Elias Mackay
his son

Through my mother's side, not my father's! Perhaps I just do not know how to work this program, I don't know.

I am missing what that has to do with whether or not you have YDNA matches, either on Geni or on FTDNA. Bjorn's response is addressing reasons you might not see YDNA matches on Geni even if such matches exist, or see the results propagated.
If you have no YDNA matches at FTDNA, then you will have no YDNA matches on Geni. Do yo have YDNA matches at FTDNA?

I just went to your 5th great grandfather, clicked the pushpin, then clicked on your name and it told me "Robin Mackey is Elias Mackey's fifth great grandson" and when I expand it the path goes thru your father, etc.
If you go to your profile, click Actions, click Ancestor Report, and increase to enough generations, you should be able to get to any ancestor without searching on google or whatever.

Discussing paths on Geni is a completely separate topic from discussing YDNA matches. One has nothing to do with the other.

Have you upgraded your DNA kit since you connected it to Geni? FTDNA will not update Geni with the new results automatically, so you have to disconnect/reconnect the kit to the Geni profile to get in and propagate the new results.

You could in any case log in on FTDNA and disconnect/reconnect the DNA kit under:

https://www.familytreedna.com/my/partner-applications

In any case you get many matches when searching an Elias Mackey and selected the wrong one, - I guess this is the profile you was looking for, and as you can see your YDNA is propagated to him: Elias Mackey

However: You cannot expect a DNA match to any person without having a test of that person to compare with. Even if you was able to locate the burial place of your 5th great grandfather I doubt that there is anything left of him you can extract DNA from.

About even getting matches: I seem to be alone both on Geni and FTDNA with Y haplogroup R-FT88577, - no matches at all at 111 and 67 Markers. First on YDNA-37 I get two.
The only hope for getting Y-DNA matches is to encourage a relative which should match to take a test to confirm the line.

Bjorn, Thank you. As I stated before, Elias Mackey at Barbourville, Kentucky, USA, is definitely confirmed as my 5ggf., and he is in the Mackey Cemetery there at Mackey Bend on the Cumberland River. My question is more that why he only shows up as a cousin through my mother's side and not as a paternal grandfather?

Lois, Thank you for your response also. Yes, I do have matches at FTDNA, in fact I have tested every level through Big Y-700. It's probably all because I don't know how to use these sites completely. Again, thank you.

Showing all 8 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion