From Marblehead VR, I know there are two people named William Pedrick - "William, s. Samuel and Elizabeth, bp. Sept. 24, 1738." (William Pedrick) and "William, s. Joseph and Sarah, bp. Feb. 26, 1737-8." (Captain William Pedrick).
From Marblehead VR, I know one married "Elisabeth Lambert, Jan. 21, 1762." and the other married "Mary Barker, Aug. 11, 1763."
From Marblehead VR, we have the death records of both men - "William, Capt, Oct. 24, 1803, a. 65 y. 8 m. 7 d. GR3" and "William, suddenly, June 1, 1809." With the info from the death record, I can determine that the William that died in 1803 is the son of Joseph and Sarah.
Unfortunately, there is no info in either the marriage or death records to help determine which William married which lady.
Roland Henry Baker, III - You have worked with both men. Perhaps, you can tell which one married which lady.
https://peoplelegacy.com/capt_william_pedrick-295U7e has the son of Joseph and Sarah as the wife of Mary Barker. This website is similar to Find A Grave.
Hello again Emily!
See The Essex Genealogist 14:149
http://www.americanancestors.org/databases/essex-genealogist-the/im...
Which includes the marriages for both Williams and their respective parents.
Captain William Pedrick 4 Shoreman & merchant like his father (later also called yeoman) son of Joseph Pedrick Shorman & Marchant and Sarah Martin his wife married Mary Barker.
You are correct about the death matching to the calculated birth:
Calc death Oct 24, 1803 (Gregorian) - 65 y, 8 m 7 d = Feb 17, 1738; BIRTH : 1737 LOCATION : Marblehead, Essex, Massachusetts, United States VOLUME : Marblehead - V1 PAGE : 387 TEXT : Will[ia]m, s. Joseph and Sarah, bp. Feb. 26, 1737-8. C.R.1
Marblehead VR: MARRIAGE : 1763 LOCATION : Marblehead, Essex, Massachusetts, United States VOLUME : Marblehead - V2 PAGE : 325 TEXT : William, and Mary Barker, Aug. 11, 1763.; The Essex Genealogist 14:149
He is buried in the same plot as his wife Mary:
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/31427146/william-pedrick
Essex Probate case 2114 for William Pedrick Shoreman, merchant & yeoman includes an administrative bond dated 6 Feb 1804 by his widow Mary Pedrick, William Pedrick, Jr cooper, and John Barker Pedrick, fisherman all of Marblehead. It also includes a dispute between said Mary widow and her daughter Hannah Pedrick and her first husband Elijah Roberts:
http://www.americanancestors.org/databases/essex-county-ma-probate-...
The other William Pedrick 4 son of Samuel and Elizabeth Oakford is also in The Essex Genealogist above. He married first Elizabeth Lambert and second Sarah (Cruff)[Dennis]Cowen/Gowain.
The William Pederick who died suddenly on 1 Jun 1809 was William Pedrick 5 born 1767 son of William Pedrick 4 and Elizabeth Lambert. He married Rebecca Homan.
Probate Case # 21115 William Pedrick fisherman includes a bond of administration by Rebecca Pedrick, widow, Nathan Brown, Esq and Benjamin Homan, clockmaker all of Marblehead dated 19 July 1809
https://www.americanancestors.org/databases/essex-county-ma-probate...