Jakob Neumann - Problems with this profile

There is a big problem with this profile. It goes way beyond the first problem, mentioned in the note, "no record found, birth date like brother Moritz". This is significant since the birth records have survived for this place and time,

The second problem is that not only is there a birth record of each of the sons of Jacob Neumann (1801 - before 1890) and Theresia Basch, but each of the birth specifies which son each one is, as First Son, Second Son, etc. (in German). There is no gap where Jacob Jr. could fit in.

A third problem is that Ashkenazi Jews virtually never named a son with the same name as the father. Also, children were usually named after someone who was deceased.

So, unless there is some other evidence to the contrary, it is almost impossible that this Jakob Neumann b. 1942 could be the son of Jakob Neumann b. 1801.

Possibly DNA connections, as well as more careful record searches, can throw some light on this.