Johannes Tobias Nel - Which Isabella should be his mother?

Leon Johan Pierre van Aswegen, a1b1c5d2e5f7g5h3

Hmm - the two fathers Stephanus Jacobus Daniel Nel, e2f2 and Andries Francois Nel, d3e9 also have different parents.

I'm just going to undo the merge, Leon. Thanks for noticing.

So we now have two different Johannes Tobias Nels
Johannes Tobias Nel and
Johannes Tobias Nel
both sons of two different Andries Francois Nel, d3e8 and Isabella Elisabeth van Staden Nels

Married to two different Martha Sophia Nels
Martha Sophia Nel and
Martha Sophia Nel

Too many coincidences here - Something is drastically wrong - but I can't figure out what because none of the profiles are sourced :-(

Marie Vermeulen-Boshoff and Private User

Private User

No hold on...

Stephanus Jacobus Daniel Nel, e2f2

He is not Andries Francois, but Stephanus Jacobus Daniel. In 2019 someone just renamed the profile :/

Renaming him back...

Similarly, S J D Nel's wife was Mynhardt, just renamed by the same user yesterday.

Reporting

Johanna Catharina Nel

Believe the original question is now resolved. Not sure about the one of 6:23 PM.

For flips sake!! Thanks Jan.

:) Good choice of words.

:-)

Sharon Doubell and Jan Marthinus Blomerus, b2..h1, there seems to still be something wrong here.

I sourced the supposed husband of Martha Sophia Nel, Johannes Tobias Nel based on his parents and death date but his wife mentioned, is different from Martha Sophia. Unless they omitted listing another spouse.

The death date of Johannes Tobias' Spouse according to his DN is also 25 July 1920 as is Martha Sophia's?

Herewith the [https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C913-HSTG-T?i=224&... DN] for easy reference

Regards

Herewith also the supposed correct wife's IOD

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-G5FZ-9JV1?i=135&am...

And the probate

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C9BY-36F6?i=642&am...

This Johannes Tobias Nel

'New' wife: Susannah Elizabeth Nel

So
Susannah Elizabeth Erasmus Nel (1842 Winterberg Cape Province - 25 Jul 1920 Komgha)

do Mechiel Daniel Erasmus & Anna Catharina Peek Erasmus (both deceased)

x Johannes Tobias Nel

Anna Catrina x widow of Jacobus Petrus Van Der Merwe Probate 1920
Stephanus Jacobus Daniel Nel
Michael Daniel Nel
Johannes Hermanus Nel
Benjamin Daniel Nel
Martha Laurina (deceased)
Petrus Rasmus Erasmus Nel
Johanna Catrina Nel Botha x Christoffel Johannes Botha

Johannes Tobias Nel (1836 Albany Cape Province - 08 Jul 1924 Komgha)

so Stefanus Jacobus Daniel Nel & Johanna Catrina Mynard

x Susannah Elizabeth Erasmus Nel

Anna Catrina x Jacobus Petrus Van Der Merwe
Stefanus Jacobus Daniel Nel
Michael Daniel Nel
Johannes Hermanus Nel
Benjamin Daniel Nel
Martha Lauvina
Petrus Rasmus Erasmus Nel
Johanna Catrina x Christoffel Johannes Botha

So Johanna Catharina Petzer and Barend Jacobus Petrus Nel

are the children of Martha Sophia Nel and a different Johannes Tobias Nel?

This one Johannes Tobias Nel ?

married to this Martha Sophia Nel

I've moved Johanna Catharina Petzer & Barend Jacobus Petrus Nel to have parents acc to their DBs: Jan Tobias Nel & Martha Sophia Nel

So now Johannes Tobias Nel & Susannah Elizabeth Nel need to have the children on their DNs added to them.

Thanks Danie

Sharon Doubell Thank you, I have added the children according to Johannes Tobias Nel's DN to their profiles, didn't want to muddy the water further earlier.

thanks.