• Join - It's Free

Hyman Epstein - Coincidence or Error

Started by Private User on Sunday, July 9, 2023
Problem with this page?

Participants:

  • Private User
    Geni Pro

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 4 posts

Geni currently has 2 Hyman Epsteins who died on the same day in the same place:

Hyman Epstein = Chaim / Hyman Yosef Ben Eliash Epshtein - son of Bentsel and Batsheva, (first cousins), born about 1847
Chaim / Hyman Yosef Ben Eliash (Epstein) Epshtein = Chaim / Hyman Yosef Ben Eliash Epshtein - son of Son of Eliash and Chaya

Are both listed as died September 10, 1923 in Brooklyn, Kings County, New York, United States

There is a New York City Certificate of Death https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000196173836903&...
for Chaim Epstein, son of Elias Epstein and Unknown on September 10, 1923 in Brooklyn

Place of death and usual residence is 62 Lewis Ave, same as on 1920 Census for Chaim / Hyman Yosef Ben Eliash Epshtein with his wife and children

Mark Harold Melmed -
You added and are sole manager of the Hyman Epstein who son of Bentsel and Batsheva -- and the only person who edited it so far.
Given the date of birth shown for it, and the date of birth shown for Batsheva, it seems there is no way he can be Batsheva's child.

Unless you provide some reason not to, I am going to merge him with the profile currently shown as Chaim / Hyman Yosef Ben Eliash (Epstein) Epshteim and then discinnect him from Bentsel and Batsheva - as parents

(See post above for links)

Not having heard any objection, I have merged the two Hymans, and removed Bentsel and Batsheva, as parents.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion