Elizabeth Throckmorton - Fictitious Person?

Started by Private User on Thursday, September 18, 2014
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing 1-30 of 82 posts

There is so much wrong with this profile that it's hard to know where to begin.

*For starters, her birth date is *ONE YEAR* after her mother's birth date.
*For seconds, she is supposed to have lived to be 100 (possible, but doubtful).
*For thirds, no source has ever cited *this* Elizabeth Throckmorton, with *these* parents, as a wife for Sir Thomas Dale.
*She would probably have been a good twenty years older than Sir Thomas Dale (his birth date dies not exist, but he first comes to public attention in 1587-88 as a low-ranking campaigner in the Netherlands - c. 1560 to no later than 1570 seems reasonable).
*She would have been over 60 when she married Sir Thomas Dale in 1611 - *the marriage, and the date, are documented*.
*How could she possibly have had a daughter at 60-plus years old?
*How could she have had *this* daughter at *any* age? (Probable birth date c. 1719!!!!!)

IMHO this profile is either fictitious, or thoroughly rubbished by well-meaning (mis)managers (self included).

Visitations of Suffolk says there was an Elizabeth Throckmorton who was the daughter of Sir Lionel Throckmorton and Elizabeth Blennerhassett - but she married a Richard Vynor of St. Lawrence.

*That* Elizabeth Throckmorton Elizabeth Throckmorton has been located, properly mated, and stabilized with descendants as per Visitations of Suffolk.

Maven just curious ...are you saying that this person is fictitious

Sir Thomas Dale
Dale
by
Peter ten Arve
Vaughn Baker

Elizabeth Throckmorton

Lady Dale, Elizabeth Throckmorton, was the daughter of Sir Thomas Throckmorton and Elizabeth Berkeley. Thomas Throckmorton was the High Sheriff of Gloucester, as had been his father, grandfather, and great grandfather Throckmorton. These Throckmortons had descended from a cadet branch of the much older Throckmortons of Coughton Court. John Throckmorton (1412-1436) had settled in Bristol and purchased a ship to trade with Iceland. In his short life, he managed to establish great wealth, but also married quite well into the wealthy merchant family Brugge (also Brydges). Coincidentally, we believe that Thomas Gates descended from this family.

The great grandfather of Lady Dale also married well and this marriage brought the Manor of Tortworth into the Throckmorton family. Tortworth was just several villages south of the ancient fortress, Berkeley Castle.

Lady DaleÂ’s mother was the daughter of Sir Richard Berkeley of Stoke-Gifford (on the northern outskirts of Bristol). These were the Berkeleys who settled Berkeley Plantation on the James River. The Berkeleys were a very old family with ties to the Royal family. Most recently, the Third Baron Berkeley (1505-1581) had been King Henry VIIIÂ’s standard bearer. It was probably Grandfather Sir Richard Berkeley, who was Lieutenant of the Tower of London in 1597. Sir Richard had married the daughter of William Read of Rendcombe in Gloucester. We believe it was the same Sir William Read who we found listed in the year 1588 in Middlesex as the Sergeant Major for the protection of the Queen as England established defenses against the Spanish invasion.

One of the most famous military families of that time was that of Lord Chandos, the Brugge family, and they were inter-related with both the Throckmortons and Berkeleys. They were located at Sudeley castle less than ten miles north of Rendcombe, and only six miles from previously mentioned Tewkesbury. Sir Charles Brugge had refused to execute Queen Elizabeth when she was just a young princess, and Queen Elizabeth visited Sudeley to pay respect to the family. Sir John Brugge was a Captain in the Low Countries with Sir Thomas Dale in 1609.

Lady DaleÂ’s extended family was very involved in the wars abroad:

We believe it was Brother John Throckmorton who was in 1616 second in command of the Sidney Regiment in the Low Countries. He was married to the daughter of the Baron of the Exchequer of England, and we believe he was also the secretary to the 2nd Earl of Pembroke.
Brother-in-law Sir Thomas Baskerville was a distinguished soldier of the Low Countries, and was knighted as a result of his actions at Cadiz where he died. Her nieces and nephews by the Baskerville marriage were both politically connected.
Her uncle was Sir John Tracey of Toddington, also a veteran of the Low Countries. TraceyÂ’s daughter married Sir Horace Vere, Baron Vere of Tilbury, who was one of the most distinguished English leaders of the Low Countries. It was his brother Sir Francis Vere who had approved Thomas Dale to be a provisional captain in 1603. Of course, Horace VereÂ’s children were all married to major military or political figures of the period. Toddington was located near Sudeley Castle and slightly more than ten miles from Tewksbury.
Tilbury was the location in 1588 where the English army mustered in preparation for the Spanish invasion. Sir Ralph Lane of the Roanoke voyages was Muster Master, and had been quite involved for the previous year in preparing various English towns for possible Spanish attack.

Lady Dale had plenty of political horsepower on both sides of her immediate family:

Her Uncle William Berkeley of Stoke-Gifford was married to the daughter of Sir William Paulet, Lord Marquess of Winchester who was a member of ElizabethÂ’s Privy Council. The Marquis was the top military Lord for EnglandÂ’s defense against the Spanish, and responsible for Hampshire in the year 1588.
Her father had taken as his second wife, the daughter of another Privy Council member, Sir Edward Rogers. Rogers had been a member of WyattÂ’s Rebellion with Sir Thomas Wyatt whose grandson would also become a Virginia Governor.
Lady DaleÂ’s niece was married to the brother of George Talbot, the ninth Earl of Shrewsbury, whose ancestor was both Privy Council Member with Rogers and Paulet, as well as the Earl Marshall for England.

Lady DaleÂ’s family also reflected the Virginia experiment in North America:

Brother Baronet William Throckmorton was one of the four stockholders behind BERKELEY Plantation in Virginia. We have been intrigued by a 1609 disposition at Clearwell by a John Dale, son of Edward Dale. Clearwell at that time was William ThrockmortonÂ’s father-in-lawÂ’s home place.
Another Berkeley Plantation founder was second cousin George Thorpe, grandson of her aunt Margaret Throckmorton, as was first cousin Richard Berkeley of Stoke- Gifford. RichardÂ’s son Maurice had married the daughter of Sir Edward Coke, Chancellor of England.
Her brother John ThrockmortonÂ’s children were actually in Virginia. Her cousin and soldier Sir John Tracey was married to the daughter of famous Low Country soldier Sir Thomas Shirley, whose other daughter was married to DaleÂ’s friend, Virginia Governor Thomas West, Lord de la Warr. West named SHIRLEY plantation immediately north of BERKELEY after his wife Cecily SHIRLEY.
Two of Cousin Horace VereÂ’s daughters were married to major Virginia Company investors, and his son-in-law Lord Paulett inherited WESTOVER plantation that was adjacent to BERKELEY Plantation.
First cousin William Tracey purchased her brotherÂ’s share in BERKELEY, and TraceyÂ’s daughter married Captain Nathaniel Powell, a member of the original Virginia Company.

The Throckmorton family had collected other manors over their two hundred years tenure in Gloucester. In fact, at the time of his death in 1607, Sir Thomas passed along fourteen manors like Tortworth. At least two of his manors were located near manors of the Earl of Leicester. Leicester was one of most powerful men in England before his death in 1588, and we learned that Sir Thomas Throckmorton and Leicester shared a daily carriage to ElizabethÂ’s court when they were in London.

We donÂ’t know London history, but could not resist commenting on the intersection of Throgmorton (Throckmorton) Street and Throgmorton (Throckmorton) Avenue in the City of London. That is the location of the Drapers house, headquarters for the Drapers Guild, and the stock exchange. We mention the Drapers Guild because it appears that Thomas Dale did descend from a family that spent many generations in the haberdasher trade, and the stock exchange because Sir Thomas ThrockmortonÂ’s actions created the beginning that would end in the pauperÂ’s house for his great grandchildren.

Throgmorton Street is only four blocks from Milk Street where the Parish Church of Matthew Dale, haberdasher, was located. Milk Street was adjacent to St. PaulÂ’s Cathedral and in the same neighborhood as the home of Dr. Valentine Dale.

Lady DaleÂ’s father, Sir Thomas Throckmorton, had been a courtier to ElizabethÂ’s court. He was influential, he had been the High Sheriff, and he was a Justice of the Peace. But he was a plotter, a manipulator, and it was not above him to tamper with juries, bribe officials, and threaten the lives of those that got in his way. The Star Chamber, the high court of England, eventually fined him heavily and sentenced him to imprisonment. Throckmorton shared a daily carriage with the Earl of Leicester, a man who was thought to have poisoned the husband of his first wife, the 1st Earl of Essex, so he could marry his wife. Later he was thought to have poisoned Sir Nicholas Throckmorton who Leicester felt had hampered his chances to marry Queen Mary of Scotland. Can you just imagine the conversations of these two predators?

At the time of his death, Sir Thomas Throckmorton left a vast fortune, but each of his fourteen manors had litigation attached. Son Baronet William Throckmorton inherited the manors and made a valiant attempt to improve the financial situation. He pioneered the harvesting of oilseed for soapmaking, re-opened the medieval ironworks that had once been profitable on Tortworth Manor, and invested in BERKELEY plantation in Virginia. It wasnÂ’t enough and he sold Tortworth Manor, the main Throckmorton home, to his cousin by marriage, Sir Horace Vere. He continued to sell off the other thirteen manors, and the last one sold was Corse Court Manor in 1632. That same year, a judgement was served in Virginia against the BaronetÂ’s son, Nicholas Throckmorton, and Lady Dale. Nicholas Throckmorton, the keeper of Kingswood Forest in Gloucester, died in 1664, and left his wife and six children destitute.

Although Thomas Dale died in 1619, Lady Dale continued to live for two more decades until 1639. However, an administration against the estate of Thomas Dale in 1633 is much clearer. It stated that Thomas Dale, of parts beyond the seas, was to have his estate assigned to Thomas Burnett, principal creditor, and the relict was "unanswering". Obviously, DaleÂ’s estate had been attached because of the tremendous Throckmorton debt inherited some twenty-five years earlier. William Burdett, who had been at DALES GIFT in 1624 had become the caretaker of Lady Dale's estate in Virginia, and we are left with the question if the 1633 administration is not that of Burdett's son, Thomas Burdett, who we found living on a section of the original Dales estate a few years later.

Two men were named as the executors of her will and rightful heirs. The first was Richard Hanby whose neice was married to Lady Dale's nephew. We also found a record of a Thomas Dale (W1578) of Alford, and his wife Anne Hanby of Malley, thinking that there may be a connection. As of yet, we have not been able to link them further.

With the help of modern day Shrimptons, we were able to identify the William Shrimpton of White Church in Southampton mentioned by Ralph Whitelaw, as William Shrimpton (D1661), probable son of yeoman Francis Shrimpton (D1608) of Bassing in Hampshire, and husband of Margaret Deane. Lady Dale had referred to him as a deserving friend, however, we were unable to identify any other direct connections with the Dales. Shrimpton's parish, White Church in Hampshire is less than seven miles east of Andover, where we located the birthplace of Dales's friend, Baron de la Warr, as well as the Dale's of Fyfield. Shrimpton's children were babtized in that parish church from 1613 to 1617. Certainly this confirmation places additional weight on Thomas Dale being a descendant of the same branh of Dales as Dr. Valentine Dale.
orthampton County - misc court records (William and Mary College Quarterly)

William and Mary College Quarterly Historical Papers, Vol.
1, No. 3. (Jan., 1893), pp. 155-156.

NORTHAMPTON COUNTY.Page 156

Will of Dame Elizabeth Dale. Dat. 4 July, 1640, Rec.(1) 2
Dec. 1640. Debts to be paid out of her estate in East India Co.
and in Va.; "ueece Mrs Dorothy Throgmorton to have 500 acres
in Va."; Edward Hambye to have all her land in Charles Hunt-
dred in Va.; "her ould servant Hannah Pickering to have L100
lawful English money." Residue in two equal parts of which
one she gives to the children of Sir William Throgmorton,
Knight Baronet, and the other to Mr. Richard Hambye and Mr.
William Crimpton; gives her nephew, the Viscount Gondamore,
a Ring of tenn pds price: mentions "Richard Hambye, Mr.
Richard Hambye's sone." The mark of Dame Elizabeth Dale.
"Mr. Wm. Schrimpton of Whitechurch in the Co. of South:
Gent and Richard Hambye of the citty of Weston in the County
of Midd, Gent, exors of the will of Dame Elizabeth Dale, late
wife and sole exx of Sir Thomas Dale, knt. deced, etc." [their
deed to Samuel Chandler of London, merchant, "now bound for
Virginia," dated last of August, 1641.]

No, what we had was a thoroughly messed-up profile for Elizabeth Throckmorton and some very bad information on Sir Thomas Dale.

Apparently two or more Elizabeth Throckmortons from two or more branches of the family had gotten hashed together - they have since been sorted out - and somebody somewhere had been doing some WAGging about Sir Thomas Dale's antecedents and (nonexistent) descendants.

Simply put, he didn't have any descendants. No comment on his brother(s), though.

Thanks, Angus - that was one of the trees I just got through unscrambling. :-)

Ok carry on, you are way ahead of me...lol

The more we MP and add sources and good Abouts to these 16th and 17th century families, the better off we'll be. And dates and locations for birth / death. Even a circa date. We need to have more information to help people not confuse people with the same name when there is little info on the profile.

Even then, field locking may be needed.

I have re-attached the Elizabeth Throckmorton that was removed as dau. of Elizabeth Throckmorton & Sir Thomas Throckmorton, MP, of Tortworth and merged her in with Elizabeth Dale.

From my records they were the parents she was originally attached to and she had the death date of 1640, but no husband or other connections.
She was probably miss-merged at one time or moved for no reason as she has no other connections but the parents, I am listed as a co-manager, I did not enter a profile for a Elizabeth Throckmorton dau. of William Throckmorton, 1st Baronet & Cecilia Baynham, but did for Elizabeth Berkeley & Thomas Throckmorton.

Crazy the way profiles get moved around.

It's been a really messy situation. Some people seem to have spent a lot of time chasing wild hares and getting parts of the tree scrambled in the process.

There still is an "Elizabeth Throckmorton" profile out there with a "Nancy Dale" m. "Unknown Hanks" hanging off it - that one was apparently based on a WAG (and some very, very bad date estimating) regarding the ancestry of A. Lincoln.

I'll MP Elizabeth Dale & Governor Sir Thomas Dale

Hopefully that will help keep them from getting into so much trouble.

Now that they're all tidied up, that's a good idea.

Am working the hypothesis that the Dales *are* blood relatives of the Hambys - it fits almost too well (and I distrust things that fit too well).

Again, all the Elizabeth Throckmortons should be MPed AND have dates / locations / Abouts. Otherwise they'll be merged in the future by someone well meaning.

Here is the first one Maven showed us http://www.geni.com/family-tree/index/6000000016094733860

The other Elizabeth Elizabeth Throckmorton

Hatte go ahead and MP

Private User

Has MP'd this one Elizabeth Throckmorton

Okay, I MPed two but really the people who create a profile should add dates / locations / About / Sources. I messaged the managers of the Elizabeth Throckmorton who has no information to do so.

Sadly I'm not entirely convinced Elizabeth Dale is correctly located in the tree.

What's bothering me is the will of Sir Thomas (d 1607)

From http://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1558-1603/member/th...

"The bulk of his property he left to his surviving son, with small annuities to his daughter, and to his ‘right honest and loving brother’ Anthony Throckmorton, who, with Sir Henry Poole, was named as overseer of the will. "

We've already identified this "Papist" daughter as Margaret

http://www.kateemersonhistoricals.com/TudorWomenT.htm

MARGARET THROCKMORTON (d.1607+)
Margaret Throckmorton was the daughter of Sir Thomas Throckmorton of Tortworth, Gloucestershire (1538/9-January 31, 1607) and Ellen Berkeley (d. before 1559). In 1593, she was committed to the custody of the Dean of Gloucester as a "verie obstinate Recusant." Her mother (actually her stepmother, Elizabeth Rogers) was blamed for "perverting" her children, since Sir Thomas was a Protestant. He left her a small annuity when he died.

In addition, this site
http://govthomasdale.blogspot.com/2011/11/lady-dale-elizabeth-throc...

identifies Lady Dale's brother as

"Brother John Throckmorton"

We believe it was Lady Dale’s brother, forty-three year old Colonel John Throckmorton , who was a long time soldier in the Low Countries, and he possibly was the second-in-command of the Sydney Regiment in 1616, when Throckmorton was the appointed Governor of Flushing, a significant posting as it had been held by some of England’s most famous soldiers.   The regiment was named after Sir Philip Sydney, brother-in-law of Henry Herbert, 2nd Earl of Pembroke.   It was most likely this same John Throckmorton who was personal secretary to Henry Herbert, and Throckmorton apparently married Anne Southey of Rimpton. ...."

But Sir Thomas' son John dsp. Again from HOP:

"The bulk of his property he left to his surviving son ..."

So we have only two surviving children of Sir Thomas:

- Margaret the Papist
- William, 1st Bt.

What say you?

Private would love your insight if any ...

Take *everything* from the "govthomasdale.blogspot.com" site with a sizable dose of salt. The person maintaining it is at best a "conspiracy theorist" type writer (*everything* is connected, significant and meaningful) and at worst an Emma Siggins White wannabe (people are related because I say they are).

Research quality is haphazard and sometimes nonexistent, and in several cases the conclusions were obviously, blatantly wrong. For instance, the Isabella Dale who married somebody Gayner could NOT have been the same Isabel(la) who married Edward Douglas and Rev. Teackle. (I wound up interpreting them as aunt and niece, and am not convinced that's the right explanation.)

As for the "History of Parliament" article, it was written in 1981, and I would really like to see it updated with current research. Some of the older articles were really slapdash and haphazard - and got "unimportant" details (like numbers of children) wrong.

On the other hand we have the explicit evidence of Lady Elizabeth Throckmorton Dale's will that she *is* closely related to Sir William Throckmorton, "Knight Baronet" - who was by then deceased, as she left legacies to his children.

And can we be *sure* that John Throckmorton d.s.p.? "My niece Mistress Dorothea Throgmorton" had to come from somewhere, doesn't seem to be one of Sir William's children, and I don't think she was found under a cabbage leaf.

Thomas Dale's will mentions brother in law Sir William Throckmorton, kn't, and Bar't.

Curiously, we do in fact have a "John Throgmorton" living in Virginia in 1624, and on the Eastern Shore at that. (Hotten, Original Lists, p. 189.)

He is also in the Muster List for the following year, cited as "age 24" (so he isn't Lady Dale's brother - but maybe nephew?), as coming over in the "William & Thomas" in 1618, and in association with a "Chyna Boyse aged 26 years in the "Georg" [sic] in May 1617" and three "Servant's" (Edward Sparshott, 31, Sea Flower 1621; Francis Downing, 24, Returne 1624, Ellis Ripping, 23, Returne 1624).

We should be able to get Thomas Throckmorton (d 1607)'s will; I already added the index reference to his profile.

HOP article is clear that
- son John pre deceased his father; other refs give age 18
- son 1st Bt inherited an encumbered 14 manors
- one daughter, raging Papist, small annuity in will. Otherwise identified as Margaret, no known spouse or children.

I don't see this Elizabeth in this generation.

Sorry !

Son John BTW is also sourced dsp in Visitations 1623.

And Cracroft's Peerage doesn't have her; they've been pretty good on this family.

Keep looking ... I suspect she belongs in a later generation & there are other throgmorton lines.

Ther may be "other Throckmorton lines", but most of them were fanatically Catholic. The Coughton Court lot were up to their ears in the Gunpowder Plot, and barely managed to escape prosecution.

I checked up on the Visitations of Gloucestershire. *No one* signed off on the Throckmorton/Throgmorton family, which probably means the heralds were going off public records (as they certainly were for the compiled continuations below).

There are *no daughters at all* listed for Sir Thomas, yet we know he had *at least* one.

Cracroft is primarily interested in baronets and up, and doesn't report *any* siblings for Sir William Throckmorton. Not even known (supposedly "d.s.p.") brother John.

Showing 1-30 of 82 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion