Agnes Borthwick - Daughter of 3rd or 4th Lord William Borthwick?

The identity of Agnes Borthwick is uncertain. However, it seems quite unlikely, improbable even, that she was a daughter of the fourth Lord Borthwick. After all, the fourth lord does not appear to have been married until 1491 http://clanborthwick.com/lineage12.htm whereas Agnes was already the wife of David Kennedy on 9 July 1489 https://archive.org/stream/registrummagnisi02scot#page/395/mode/1up Agnes Borthwick died before 9 August 1509, by which date her widowed husband had already married for a second time to Margaret Boyd, the dowager Lady Forbes https://archive.org/stream/registrummagnisi02scot#page/721/mode/1up

I agree.

Thankyou for the comprehensive and well-researched update to her profile, Private User. I've moved her accordingly, and added a Curator note.

If we can verify their children, I will lock the profile's relationships.

Dear Sharron,

I am pleased that you have accepted my proposal. The Kennedy family is not at the top of my list at the moment but I will try to have a look at the evidence for Agnes Borthwick's children at some point in the future.

Can I point out that someone has posted a "Confirmed Match" which is wrong. The same is also included in "Sources". I don't suppose that this is particularly important, although it might mislead other researchers, but it is untidy.

Kind Regards,

Neil

I've undone the erroneous confirmed match. Thanks for noticing.

If you get to the kids, just call me back to lock for you. Until then, this is a lot better than it was :-)