• Join - It's Free

Charlemagne and William the Conqueror descent

Started by Jessica Christophe-Dymock Paternal Ydna QM 242 on Tuesday, November 19, 2019
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Showing all 4 posts

I am pretty surprised centuries of people could keep on saying we all descend of Charlemagne or William the Conqueror.

The Frank kindgom counted approx 15 million people, GB around 13 million.

If Charlemagne had wanted everyone to descend from him, he would have needed to have sex with AT LEAST 7.5 MILLION WOMEN for the franks alone.

It's similar for the Conqueror. Especially more since he is known to have been one of the most faithful rulers in history.

So, NO, Charlemagne did not have sex with 7 million women, and the Conqueror could not hav3 conquered and fertilized 5/6 million women.

Thank you. It's called a rant.

It's actually a result of something called "pedigree collapse" or "implex", due to the absolute impossibility of having that many separate ancestors that long ago (the "rice/wheat on a chessboard" exponential thing).

Sooner or later (*much* sooner in the case of nobility, who were always having to send off for Papal dispensations), two people related in some degree come together, get married and have children, lather rinse repeat until everyone is at least distantly related to everyone else.

My paternal grandfather and grandmother were 8th cousins, although they probably never knew it. And as for my mother's side of the family - that was one reason among many why people started *leaving* Calitri, to find people to marry who weren't too closely related to them.

Paternal grandmother, in fact, had a rather nasty little Nest in her recent background - *her* paternal grandfather and grandmother were half-first cousins! (That's the lower Eastern Shore for you - too many people, too little space, and no wonder they started leaving in droves about that time.) Not that she knew *that* either.

Try it yourself with a calculator. Keep multiplying 2 x 2 and see how fast it gets out of hand. :-)

Jessica Christophe-Dymock Paternal Ydna QM 242 and Private User - I think it is so true that we find these interconnections from generations back. My father's family is so entrenched in the Southeastern US descending from Welsh, Scots, English, and a smattering of German that it was a situation many times in families of cousins marrying cousins knowingly and most often unknowingly. He always said he went as far away as possible in finding a wife who was a first generation American with parents from western Finland.

Geni has given me a different perspective as I find my father's Scottish roots have the blood of Vikings and yes, I am finding connections by blood and marriage to some of my Finnish/Swedish tree. So I suspect the reality of "pedigree collapse" is more common than we can imagine. I have come to appreciate Maven's post of "I'm My Own Grandpa" more every day.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion