Henriette BODENHEIM (Rothschild) - Families mistakenly clumped together in MH trees?

Started by Private User on yesterday
Problem with this page?

Participants:

  • Private User
    Geni member
  • Private User
    Geni member

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 7 posts

These two profiles seem initially different by birth and death dates and locations however in many MH trees the surrounding family (husband, parents and/or siblings are the same or quite similar:
Henriette Bodenheim vs
Henriette Bodenheim

This should be further investigated in depth before attempting to merge the profiles...

Thanks,
Theo

According to the Hebrew inscription of the first Henriette gravestone (which does'nt match
the German inscription, but I believe is correct) she was born on 6 Feb 1820 and died on
16 Sep 1871. We still need to verify if she as the same as the second Henriette.

I also found in Ancestry a profile of Henriette who was married to Gustav, so it seems those profiles are different

In JewishGen the same profile of Henriette (2) born in 1812 , married to Gustav,
had a son Gustav who died on 1905 in Kassel. Unfortunately, we only have the index of his death,
but not the record to verify his parents.

I didn't calculate the Hebrew date from the gravestone but when you wrote the initial comment on her profile about the mismatch between the dates you added "Probably born on 26/1/1810.". That is 10 years earlier!

I've seen some profiles which go with 1810 and others with 1820
And that's even beside the second Henriette quoted above which shows 1812 as her birth year (and a different town).
Maybe you could recalculate the Hebrew date again? lol

The other issues that need to be sorted out besides the husband issue is her parents and siblings... They seem to be used in various versions on all Henriette's that are spread on MH (and I assume Ancestry). So we need to figure out which parents and children belong to each other exclusively :)

I didn't calculate it. I used 2net which gives you Hebrew/Gregorian Calendar
,
and looking again at the Hebrew inscription it doesn't make sense at all as, it is written
that she was born on Friday, but the Hebrew date does'nt match Friday.

So, as I think now there is an error in the Hebrew inscription, I think the correct birth date
may be 11 Feb 1820, which was Friday and the Hebrew year and month are correct but the Hebrew day is wrong .(Should be 26 and not 21).

Showing all 7 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion