Mary J. Hanna (Cutbirth) - 2 Mary Culbirth's same B & D dates places

I got this merge message

These look o be the same but the parentage doesn't.

I think two profiles on Geni might be the same.

Here's a view of both profiles -

Mary J. Hanna
Gender: Female
Birth: July 11, 1799
Carter, Tennessee, United States
Death: September 08, 1876 (77)
Stella, Giles, Tennessee, United States
Immediate Family:
Daughter of Benjamin Robert Cuthbert, Jr. and
Elizabeth Grant Cuthbert
:

Mary J. Hanna
Gender: Female
Birth: circa 1799
Carter County, Tennessee, United States
Death: September 1876 (72-81)
Giles County, Tennessee, United States
Immediate Family:
Daughter of Daniel Boone Cutbirth and
Elizabeth Cutbirth
Wife of James Hanna, Jr.

Is itt ppossible for them to have the same birth and death dates and locations