Elizabeth Floyd (Carlisle) - Elizabeth attached to wrong Charles Floyd

On Nov. 7, 2020, I noted on the profile of Elizabeth:

Elizabeth was not married to Charles Johnston Floyd. This is a bad merge. Perhaps she was married to another relative named Charles Floyd.

Charles is Pvt. Charles Johnston Floyd, (CSA)

He was married to Sarah Jane Floyd

_________________________________________________________

From Charles' profile:

Charles Floyd enlisted in Company E, North Carolina 51st Infantry Regiment on 15 May 1862. He died on 14 May 1864 at Drewry's Bluff, VA in the Battle of Proctor's Creek.

*https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Proctor's_Creek.

Son of Francis Floyd and Christina Herring Williams

Husband of Sarah Jane Pittman

* Anice Penelope (Penny) Floyd 1855 – 1912
* Ida C. Floyd 1856 – 1870
* William P. (Willie) Floyd 1858 – 1870
* Alexander Ferdinand Floyd 1859 –
* Minnie Floyd 1860 –
* Charles ('Charley') Floyd

Note: Possible Unmarked Grave

"United States Census (Slave Schedule), 1860", database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:WK5T-GFMM : 16 October 2019), Charles J Floyd, 1860.

4 slaves in 1860.

"North Carolina, County Marriages, 1762-1979 ," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:Q2R1-NRCZ : 3 February 2017), Charles J. Floyd and Sarah Jane Pitman, 02 Mar 1854; citing Randolph, North Carolina, United States, p. p 47, North Carolina State Archives Division of Archives and History; FHL microfilm 418,149.

Wedding date March 2, 1854

"United States Census, 1860", database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MDD1-X1D : 19 March 2020), Charles J Floyd, 1860.

* Charles J Floyd Male 30 North Carolina
* Sarah J Floyd Female 27 North Carolina
* Anice P Floyd Female 5 North Carolina
* Ida C Floyd Female 4 North Carolina
* William P Floyd Male 2 North Carolina
* Alexr F Floyd Male 1 North Carolina

"United States Census, 1870", database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MW81-MRF : 18 March 2020), Sally Floyd, 1870.

* Sally Floyd Female 37 North Carolina (Sarah "Sally" Floyd, head of household)
* Penny Floyd Female 16 North Carolina (Anice P)
* Ida Floyd Female 15 North Carolina
* Willie Floyd Male 12 North Carolina
* Ferdinand Floyd Male 11 North Carolina (Alexander F.)
* Winnie Floyd Female 10 North Carolina (Born in 1860 after census)
* Charley Floyd Male 7 North Carolina (Conceived before he left for war)
* Daniel McLellan Male 24 North Carolina (Boarder)

____________________________________________________

Wikitree has some interesting information on Elizabeth Carlisle Floyd from https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Carlisle-53

Birth
Date: 1818
Place: North Carolina, United States
Source: #S405
Page: Compact Disc #74; PIN:441144
Note: Lorene Martens of Oregon submitted this information, but the marriage date is 14 Feb 1833, not the 23rd.
Source: #S406
Page: Year: 1840; Census Place: Not Stated, Pike, Alabama; Roll: 12; Page: 403.

Source: #S326
Page: Year: 1850; Census Place: Not Stated, Pike, Alabama; Roll: M432_13; Page: 172; Image: 341.
Note: Enum 15 Oct. Who are John and Flora Rankin, ages 13 and 14 who are living with family? Is Elizabeth Floyd who is living with the family, the mother of Charles? Note she is from NC, also. And who are John and James Floyd, age 18 and 16? If they are Elizabeth's children, then she was age 54 when the youngest was born-- not impossible, but not likely?

Death
Place: , Pike, Alabama

Source: #S405
Page: Compact Disc #74; PIN:441144
Note: Lorene Martens of Oregon submitted this information, but the marriage date is 14 Feb 1833, not the 23rd.

Marriage:
Date: 23 FEB 1833
Place: , Pike, Alabama, United States

Source: #S460
Page: Page 34
Source: #S405
Page: Compact Disc #74; PIN:441144
Source: #S406
Page: Year: 1840; Census Place: Not Stated, Pike, Alabama; Roll: 12; Page: 403.

Source: #S326
Page: Year: 1850; Census Place: Not Stated, Pike, Alabama; Roll: M432_13; Page: 172; Image: 341.
Sources

Source S326
Abbreviation: 1850 Census Of Pike County, Al
Title: <i>1850 Census Of Pike County, Al</i>

Source S405
Abbreviation: Pedigree Resource File; www.familysearch.org; Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-
Title: Pedigree Resource File; www.familysearch.org; Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Source S406
Abbreviation: 1840 U.S. Federal Census of Pike County, Alabama
Title: , 1840 U.S. Federal, Pike County, Alabama,;.

Source S460
Abbreviation: Floyd & Taylor, Early Floyds of Pike County, Alabama & Some of Their Descend
Title: <i>Floyd & Taylor, <i>Early Floyds of Pike County, Alabama & Some of Their Descendents (53 Cedar Knoll, Tuscaloosa, Alab</i>

_________________________________________________

Some of the Floyds from Horry, Marion, and Dillon Counties SC and Robeson and Columbus Counties, NC did move to Pike, AL and other counties nearby.

I will look to see if Charles married to Elizabeth Carlisle Floyd is one of them. Right now, I think the preponderance of information would have us detach Elizabeth Carlisle and her children from Charles Johnson Floyd, son of Francis Floyd, II and Christian Floyd I will make another Charles Floyd and try to indicate some way that they are not to be merged. May need a curator when finished.

Any other thoughts and I wander through the descendants of Francis Floyd and Isabella Floyd Lee There are many duplicate names and they need sorting. This is one of those cases, I think.