John Stewart Porterfield - Straightening out the Family

Started by Erica Howton on Sunday, March 26, 2023
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 10 posts

Managers of John Stewart Porterfield,

I am contacting you about this profile: John ‘Immigrant’ Porterfield

You have him connected to the wrong family. This John Porterfield (1675-1738), the Trenton Merchant, is often confused with his cousin, John Porterfield (1675-1739), the fore father of the Pennsylvania Porterfields.

Occupation: Merchant in Trenton, New Jersey
Religion: Presbyterian

John Porterfield (1675-1738), who came to America. New Jersey Archives, Vol. 30 P 383: "John Porterfield, merchant of Trenton, New Jersey, by will dated 1735, leaves property to brother and nephews in Scotland." Hall's History of the Presbyterian Church in Trenton, pp. 72-73: "John Porterfield died in 1738. His will, dated three years before, describes him 'of Trenton, Merchant', and devises a thousand acres on the south branch of the Raritan, and other property in east New Jersey, 'late recovered from John Drummond, Earl of Melfort', one of the noble proprietaries. It mentions his brother, Alexander, of Duchall, in Scotland, and a nephew, William Rallston of the shire of Ayr and 'Boyd Porterfield, grandson to my brother'. He bequeathed to another nephew, William Farquhar, 'chirurgeon of Brunswick, all my interest in one third part of the forge at Trenton.' (This will, as a photostatic copy shows, was written by John Porterfield, the devisor, himself and is very legibly written and properly arranged, in excellent language. The word Duchall is spelled by him who was reared at Duchall as it is written here. Evidently the Porterfields who owned the Duchall estate knew how to spell it. However, many, many other records and authors examined in the course of this reseach use the Duchal spelling, omitting the last letter.)

Sincerely,

Ron Harper

I don’t see him listed at Stirnet.

From https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/pp/porterfield1.php

  • (1) William Porterfield (dvp) m. (1671) Annabel Stewart (dau of Sir John Stewart of Ardgowan & Blackhall)
    • (A) Alexander Porterfield 'of that ilk' of Porterfield & Blacksolme (d before 14.11.1743) m1. (1694) Catherine Boyd (dau of William Boyd, 1st Earl of Kilmarnock who d 03.1692)
    • (B) Anna Porterfield probably of this generation m. Gavin Ralston of that ilk
    • (C) Jean Porterfield probably of this generation m. (1700) James Farquhar of Gilminscroft

Anna Porterfield is listed at Stirnet.

From: George Robertson, Topographical Description of Ayrshire; More Particularly of Cunninghame: Together with a Genealogical Account of the Principal Families in that Bailiwick (Cunninghame Press, Irvine, 1820), see pages 276-79 for an account of the family of Ralston of that Ilk. Page 278-279.

https://archive.org/details/topographicaldes00robe/page/278/mode/1u...

X. Gavin Ralston, the only son of the marriage, succeeded Ms father as Ralston of that Ilk. He married in 1697, Anna, daughter of Wm. Porterfield of that Ilk, by Annabella, daughter of Sir Archd. Stewart of Blackball j by whom he had a son, William, and four daughters : 1. Ursulla, married to Robert Barr of Tree- ame; 2. Annabella, married to James Maxwell of Willi am wood; 3. Jean, married to John Shedden of Roughwood, (of whom af- terwards); and 4. Katherine, married to the Rev. John Fullarton of Dairy. In 1 705 he sold the estate of Ralston to the Earl of Dundonald — from whence it has passed through different hands, and is now possessed by a family of the name of Orr. He was succeeded by his son, William …

Alexander Porterfield of that Ilk Is the brother mentioned (above). Matching details include:

'Boyd Porterfield, grandson to my brother'.
Alexander Porterfied of that Ilk made his last will and testament on 27 August 1739. In the first instance he nominated his grandson, Boyd Porterfield, to be his sole executor, but subsequently changed his mind and appointed his wife Margaret Campbell.

I’ve separated the two John Porterfields.

His origins are not proven.

Two Parentage Theories

John Porterfield and his father William are interesting in that the only known source for their existence is a letter published in The Porterfields (1947) from Colonel George Alexander Porterfield to the author in 1903.

George Alexander Porterfield's exact words were:

"We are undoubtedly descended from Alexander Porterfield and, I think, from William, the son of Alexander. After the loss of their estates, the family went first to Ireland and thence came to America, and were the first of this name to the country."[1]

William and John have some of the most tenuous of genealogical connections of Porterfield ancestors that moved to America. Most other Porterfield ancestors have older sources closer to their life events. This connection would need to be considered as family tradition.

"A Kirk without a Steeple" cites a different lineage for this John Porterfield.[2]

References

  1. Frank Burke Porterfield, The Porterfields (Roanoke, Virginia: Multiprint Inc, 1947), p. 1, 2, digital images, https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=wu.89066246737;view=1up;seq=9. Hathi Trust Digital Library (https://babel.hathitrust.org: accessed 24 October 2019).
  2. Elizabeth M Main, A Kirk without a Steeple (Cordfall Ltd., 2003), p. 27.

I don’t think this is proven.


“Kilmacolm and the Porterfields.” < link > “Late in the seventeenth century, young WIlliam Porterfield left Kilmacolm, Scotland for Ireland. His older brother, [[Alexander Porterfield of that Ilk Alexander Porterfield of that Ilk] Alexander], had inherited the family estate of Duchal when his grandfather [[John Porterfield of that Ilk John Porterfield of that Ilk] John] died. A generation later, William’s son [[John ‘Immigrant’ Porterfield John ‘Immigrant’ Porterfield] john] left County Donegal, Ireland, with his wife and family for america. They were the ancestors of the porterfields that settled in Madison County, Georgia after the American Revolution.”

Thanks for taking this on.
I'm tied up at work until later this week, but it does indeed sound like we have once again a family that too many amateur genealogists have been whacking at. As we saw with the Montgomeries, and with pretty much all the Irish immigrants in the 1600s, the origin stories are 30% real and 70% conjecture. If you throw any records at such stories they fall apart.

I'd therefore be super interested in whether there were any Irish records for the Porterfields, e.g. from the Clogher marriage records.... Stay tuned.

Chapter ll, Porterfields of Ireland. Page 48.

https://archive.org/details/porterfieldsbyfr00port/page/47/mode/1up

Erika,

Thanks for splitting these two. Great work. The two seem largely correct now.

I have spent put most of my research notes and conclusions in Wikitree, as you may have noticed.

I am a Porterfield descendant via my maternal grandmother, so this has been an area of genealogical research focus for me for quite a while. I know Ron Harper is also very knowledgeable on all thongs Porterfield.

The undocumented Stewart middle name seems to be well propagated in Ancestry.com trees, unfortunately.

I agree that the people that went to Ireland as part of the plantations are lacking documentation. We actually have alternate theories for the John from Ireland. The two generations there I would still considered unproven/uncertain.

The newest information I am aware of for John, the Immigrant, is the alternative theory from "Elizabeth M Main, A Kirk without a Steeple (Cordfall Ltd., 2003)." mentioned above. I have a copy of that small book I was able get when I visited Kilmacolm and luckily ran into a church elder at the Old Kilmacolm Church in Kilmacolm, Renfrewshire, Scotland while wandering the grounds. He saw us in the adjacent church cemetery and approached us. He drove home to pick up his keys to the church and came back and gave us a tour of the inside of the church, also. They still had many copies of the book available. There is an earlier version of this book also, with a different name. There is a small library in Kilmacolm that also has a copy of the older book, and possibly the newer book - I can't remember for sure. I am happy to forward pages about that Porterfields in the book. It has some interesting stories about the surliness of one of the later Porterfields. He was kicked out of the church and eventually let back in. This book is not available online to my knowledge. It believe it was printed in a small run for the church largely for local church members.

Definitely try scanning relevant pages and uploading to profiles.

Glad to have your research here.

Showing all 10 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion