Robert B. Caldwell - Need a curator please and thank you. This is from the inbox:

Thank you, Faustine Darsey on partial hiatus

I don't know what sources the Geni user who messaged the managers has...

This merge in December 2020 had a profile with 66 children and a profile with 32 children and a LOT of work was done after then.... Likely it was a GEdcom that created a mess?

https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=79382733730

--------------
He is now left with one wife and child which the Geni user says is the wrong wife and child...

People often like to message but they don't like to Discuss. The curator of the profile is not active.

I'll see what the DAR and FaG have.
Parents are also MP'd.
Winifred Tull and Spencer Caldwell, Sr are not.

This merge 2017 gave him wrong wife: https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=70387912320

The correct wife Mary Caldwell Mary Logan is now married to a different Robert:
Robert Caldwell, Sr.

They need merged or disambiguated, whichever is easier but will take a curator to do as BOTH men are MP'd.
DAR has Birth: 7-9-1732 LANCASTER CO PENNSYLVANIA
Death: 7-30-1806 DANVILLE MERCER CO KENTUCKY

This profile Robert Caldwell, Sr. shows
Birth: June 06, 1719
Prince George County, Virginia
Death: July 30, 1806 (87)
Danville, Boyle County, Kentucky, United States
Place of Burial: Caldwell-Irvine Cemetery, Danville, Boyle County, Kentucky, USA

the other Robert Caldwell, Sr. shows
Birth: June 06, 1732
Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
Death: June 30, 1806 (74)
Mercer County, Kentucky, United States
Place of Burial: Caldwell-Irvine Cemetery, Danville, Boyle County, Kentucky, United States

Marsha Gail Kamish
Private User

Erica Howton please see.
Colonial American profiles both MP'd seem to represent same man but who married Winifred?

Hi, Erica Howton!
According to DAR and I think the person messaging the managers of the profile --- the wife is Mary Logan but these two men have the same death date and FaG link so I think they got smushed several ways.... I do not know who Winifred is ... I can forward the message to you but I always hesitate to tag the originator of a message. Silly me!

No sharing option on the SAR for some reason:
https://www.ancestry.com/discoveryui-content/view/978267:2204
Name Robert Caldwell
Birth Date 1732
Birth Place Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Death Date 30 Jul 1806
Death Place Danville, Kentucky
SAR Membership 91068
Role Ancestor
Application Date 31 Dec 1965
Spouse
Mary Logan
Children
Robert Caldwell

https://www.ancestry.com/sharing/7388754?mark=7b22746f6b656e223a227...
Robert Caldwell in the North America, Family Histories, 1500-2000
ancestry.com
Name Robert Caldwell
Gender Male
Age 74
Birth Date 1732
Birth Place Lancaster County, PA
First Marriage Date 1754
Death Date 1806
Death Place Danville, KY
Spouse
Mary Logan
Child
James Caldwell

Winifred Tull

Winifred Watts found in 1180 trees
Winifred Watts from tree Rouse /Carter/Lambert Family Tree
Record information.
Birth 25 Oct 1720 Somerset, Montgomery, Maryland, USA
Marriage 1751 North Carolina, USA
Residence 1800 Kinston, Lenoir, North Carolina, USA
Death 18 May 1806 Lenoir, North Carolina, USA
Record information.
Father John Watts (1694-1740)
Mother Mary Margaret Caldwell PHILIPS (1685-1748)
Spouse Robert Caldwell (1715-1742)
4296 People5 Records13 Sources

Spencer Caldwell, Sr

https://www.ancestry.com/sharing/7388827?mark=7b22746f6b656e223a225... Spencer Caldwell in the Maryland, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1635-1777 ancestry.com
Name Spencer Caldwell
Gender Male
Relationship Nephew
Description Wills, Vol 40-41, 1774-1777
Individuals Listed (Name) Relationship
John Caldwell
Mary Caldwell
Wife
William Venables
Nephew
Mary Venables
Sister
John Venables
Nephew
Mary Venables
Niece
Josiah Polk
Friend
Albert Kitch
Nephew
Belly Sanford
Niece
William Caldwell
Nephew
Samuel Caldwell
Brother
Nancey Caldwell
Daughter
Spencer Caldwell Nephew
Salathiel Griffin
Neighbor
George Dayse??D
Neighbor
James Bounds
Neighbor
Josiah Polk
Friend