Anna Margaretha (Quattelbaum) Starr - Confusion of the Sisters

Debbie Gambrell

12/13/2023 at 11:56 PM

It seems notes and connections that should go with Anna Margaretha's sister Anna Barbara:

have gotten mixed into Anna Margaretha's profile notes and maritial connections.

Anna Barbara's Wiki page shows:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Quattlebaum-80

Marriages
On January 3, 1749, Anna Barbara Quattlebaum married Hans Eberhardt Kunkel [2][7] in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. All of the Quattlebaums were recorded as belonging to the Reformed Church, the Calvinist church of the Palatinate. Hans was a Lutheran. [8]

In 1751, Anna Barbara married Alexander Dailey.

And Anna Margaretha's Wiki page:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Quattlebaum-247

indicates she was only ever married to Moses Starr

I've seen where the co-mingled notes about the sisters has caused confusion in various trees, including my own, which is why I'm trying to sort them out now that I found a publication from the 1940s that has the family genealogy researched by Paul Quattlebaum and is in the Univeristy of South Carolina library, but it doesn't list much about the girls in the family other than In past years I had used the info here on Geni and elsewhere and thought Anna Margaretha was my direct ancestor but now I'm realizing her sister Anna Barbara is my direct ancestor. I found a few trees on Ancestry that have the connections accurate, best I can tell:

Anna Barbara Quattlebaum
BIRTH5 Apr 1733 Mühlheim, Alzey-Worms, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany NEW
DEATH1780 Pennsylvania, Somerset, Pennsylvania, United States NEW

sources (3)records (2)photos (1)
Family Info

Father
Petter Quattelbaum (1698–1748)

Mother
Anna Maria Barbara Von Der Hutte Herckendall (1698–1748)

Spouse
Hans Eberhardt Kunkle (1729–1813)
Married 1749

Spouse
Alexander Justice Dailey (1730–1780)
Married 1751

I'm still looking through everything, but unless there is documentation to prove otherwise, what I've seen in my current research indicates that Anna Margaretha wasn't married to a Dailey husband.

Other eyes on this to help sort and correctly connect these folks would be appreciates.

Debbie Gambrell

12/14/2023 at 12:00 AM

Wiki has Barbara Anna Quattelbaum married to Alexander Justice Dailey, who I believe is the same as this Alexander Dailey:

Alexander Dailey

and looking at the details on the profile, this Justice Dailey's info is identical to that of Alexander above:

Alexander Dailey

I don't know if his name was Alexander, Justice or Alexander Justice but they seem to be the same person and would be Anna Barbara's husband

Debbie Gambrell

12/14/2023 at 12:13 AM

Well, this shows how forgetful I'm getting at this stage of my life. I just discovered that in June of this year I posted the following on the Wiki page of Alexander Justice Dailey:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Dailey-1426

I've become fairly convinced that people have merged two men together - Justus Dailey and Alexander Daily. I found the gravestone of Justus Dailey and it says Mr. Justus Dailey - using Justus, not Justice and Dailey, not Daily. Alexander isn't used on his gravestone. Unfortunately, there don't appear to be any dates on the gravestone.
This is info copied from his Geni profile and pasted here:

https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/dailey/1584/

A putative son of Owen, Jr., was Alexander Dailey, born Stafford County, VA about 1730 and died in Nova Scotia after 1780.

After serving with Captain Nelson's Company on duty in South Carolina, Alexander Dailey was discharged in 1748.He petitioned the South Carolina Council for land which was granted in 1748.His first wife, Barbara Craft, who was from the Newberry District of South Carolina, died about 1750. Apparently Alexander, Jr., was their only issue. Alexander, Sr., married Anna Barbara Quattlebaum in about 1751 with issue Owen (1756), John (1760), William (1766), and Vines (1779?) --- all born in SC.

Alexander Dailey, Sr. and Alexander Dailey, Jr. were listed on the muster of the Captain John York's Company, South Carolina Royalists, Savannah, GA, 1 Dec 1779. Alexander Dailey, Sr. apparently fled the country with his second wife after the American Revolution and took refuge in Nova Scotia. It is presumed he died there.

https://lists.rootsweb.com/hyperkitty/list/orangeburgh_sc.rootsweb....

B. Quatlebaum was the 2nd wife of Alexander Dailey. They married in 1751 in Newberry county S.C. She was the daughter of Peter and Anna Von Der Hutte.

Anna Margaretha (Quattelbaum) Starr - Confusion of the Sisters

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion