List of Knights of Columbus Supreme Knights
- James T. Mullen February 2, 1882 May 17, 1886
- John J. Phelan May 17, 1886 March 2, 1897
- James E. Hayes March 2, 1897 February 8, 1898
- John J. Cone March 2, 1898 March 31, 1899
- Edward L. Hearn April 1, 1899 August 31, 1909
- James A. Flaherty September 1, 1909 August 31, 1927
- Martin H. Carmody September 1, 1927 August 31, 1939
- Francis P. Matthews September 2, 1939 October 14, 1945
- John E. Swift October 24, 1945 August 31, 1953
- Luke E. Hart September 1, 1953 February 19, 1964
- John W. McDevitt February 22, 1964 January 21, 1977
- Virgil C. Dechant January 21, 1977 September 30, 2000
- Carl A. Anderson October 1, 2000 February 28, 2021
- Patrick E. Kelly March 1, 2021 Present