Hi all.
I have been on Geni for only 2 months, and in that time have made major inroads in getting to know Geni, connecting up trrees, adding new profiles, etc. etc.
I am very computer literate and have had the time to do this. Sometimes in life (online and offline), we just have to appreciate that most people are not like us.
If you are reading this, you are a minority. I don't believe that most people on Geni ever read let alone contribute to a discussion.
My (limited) experience to date when I have found trees of sometimes fairly close relatives, and I have messaged them and got no response, and then I ask them in person, I get responses like: "Oh, I think I remember I put something on that site but I haven't bothered with it since." "I signed up to a free trial but I thought it expired. I didn't know I still had an account", etc.
I suspect that in most cases, people on Geni are not aware of what they are doing in detail. This may help answer Jon Thogmartin's question as to why some people lock profiles.
There was a post earlier from Michael Lancaster that said:
"When someone enters a profile with little or no information, they sabotage the serios work that some of us want to do by giving uncertain and dubious profiles, that creates merge issues and undermines the quality of the rest of the profiles. This to me is foolish, amateur and stupid waste of our time resolving near empty profiles, and people that enter such material should be banned if they posess information that could have been used to eliminate or substantiate a profile. SUCH PEOPLE WASTING MY TIME MAKE ME CROSS!"
Michael and others: I have to say that I think most people on Geni are amateur, and may be somewhat foolish. I am. I am less foolish than most. What do you expect when you have an online free to use mass market application with zero qualification level in computer skills, and in online collaboration, let alone in genealogy, required in order to join?
Come on, we need to be tolerant of those more foolish than we are. Let's help them step up the learning curve where we can. That's what I do.
There are some malicious people around, in real life as well as online. They are the minority. Maybe the person to whom this thread was originally directed is one of those people. But most of us are not malicious. We are just a little foolish and amateur, and generally welcome a friendly hand to help us be a little less foolish and a little more professional.