Roger, I'm just being very honest with you. I'm saying that Geni is clearly a place where the collaborative, shared tree is the model, and this is not a site for independent family trees. In addition to your newly-discovered Minnesota relatives, you will also discover many others--all of those who share management with you on the historic profiles, for example. At this point, since your tree is already partially merged into the "Big Tree" on Geni, there is no way to keep your remaining public profiles from being merged in with their duplicates en route to becoming master proflles. I'm asking you to consider the benefits of this system. I'd even like for you to contribute your efforts toward this system. But with or without you (and preferably *with* you, and your cooperation, the merging will go on, because that is how Geni now functions. It's really as simple as that.
I actually disagree with Erica, because I don't think you'll get any response from Geni help that you haven't already received, and we are being much more bluntly honest with you than Geni's diplomatic customer service reps will be.
The bottom line is that Geni's new and revised system, started in late August, is working, and working well. Geni is not going to change course because of a few disgruntled users, because your opinions are outweighed by the much more numerous voices of the people who are happy to be part of this system. That's just the economic truth of the situation, since Geni is at base a for-profit corporation, and its direction has been user driven. Geni has found a distinctive niche and is developing and constantly enhancing the system and technologies to make this collaborative knowledge-building happen. And it *is* happening. I suspect that if you spoke directly with Noah Tutak, Geni's President, he would tell you what I've seen him tell others, which is what I'm trying to convey to you: If this system is not what you're looking for, and if you disagree with it, then Geni is probably not the right genealogy site for you. But if you decide to stay and participate, you will hopefully gain a great deal from the process (like having wonderfully-researched master profiles for your historic ancestors).