Sarah Ann Elizabeth Hallock

(Format and text emphasis: mine, jlphawn) profile manager

Sarah Ann Elizabeth Hallock

Born: Circa 1830, Grey County, Ontario, Canada

Daughter of: Andrew Markle and Elizabeth Markle (Cook)

Sister of: Rachel M. C[h]ampaign (Markle), Irene Lake (Markle)

Wife of: James De Groat Hallock

Mother of:

• James Robert Lee Hallock
• Susan Jackson Mallory(Hallock)
• Eleanor 'Ellen' Layton Borden Bowden (Hallock)
• Elizabeth ‘Libbie’ Boyd (Hallock)
• Anna ‘Annie’ H. Smith (Hallock)
• Sarah Markle Gamble (Hallock)
• Harriet ‘Hattie’ Ann Allen (Hallock)
• Norman Hallock
• Mary ‘May’ Emogene Johnson (Hallock)
• Martha Amelia Smith, Fluhart (Hallock)
• Minerva ‘Minnie’ Louise Bliss (Hallock)
• Clara Whitney (Hallock)
• Maria Walker (Hallock)
• Wyatt Luke Hallock

Died: circa 1898 Place: Unknown/Contested: Bath, North Dakota or Carmen, Manitoba, Canada

Burial: Unknown

Timeline and Residence

===========================================================================================================================================================

Forward Note:

1. Due to incorrect transcription of various sources, one might find her maiden name spelled: Marckle, Merkle, Moerkle, Marvel, and Manville respectively.
2. There is another woman who is frequently cross-referenced with this Sarah Ann Elizabeth Hallock (Markle), here after referred to mainly as: Sarah Ann.

Two differences

• The woman not here profiled is rightfully identified as: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle. To my knowledge, there is not an immediate family connection, however, admittedly I have not spent time on unraveling one - assuming it even exists. (Example: http://hints.ancestry.com/tree/18708251/hints?hf=allhints&src=hn&fn... ) This is the recurrent 'hint'/'match':

New York City, Deaths, 1892-1902 Birth, Marriage & Death

• Birth 1830
• Death 16 Oct 1898 - New York, New York - Age: 68
• Name Anna Merkle

New York, New York, Death Index, 1862-1948 Birth, Marriage & Death

• Birth 1830
• Death 16 Oct 1898 - Manhattan - Age: 68
• Name Anna Merkle

The coincidence of name and matching birth/death years is striking.

• My second great-grandmother is more appropriately identified as: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Hallock (born Markle). She lived most of her life as a ‘Hallock’. Also, the woman not here profiled apparently died in 1898 as well, but she was in New York state.

Is it possible that her 1898 year of death has been superimposed upon my second great grandmother? Sure. But I would find that dubious since there are so many family researchers who peg that as the year, but do not associate a place of death as being New York state. Also, we know that by 1900 her husband James De Groat Hallock was referring to himself as a Widower (See his profile: Sources: US Federal Census 1900) The last two actual time/date specific references to Sarah Ann occur in:

Everitt Allen Whitney Memoirs for December 1890 (Again please refer to James' profile Overview for exact reference). She is also recorded as being a witness at daughter Clara 's wedding to Everitt Allen Whitney on April 19th, 1891 Loyal, Wisconsin.

So at the very broadest, we know she died after Clara's 1891 wedding; and before Enumeration of the 1900 US Census

It would be easy to confuse the two Sarah Ann Elizabeth's were it not for married surname, and known place of death: New York (at least for one of them) and ‘assumed’ of either Bath, North Dakota or Carmen, Manitoba, Canada for the other. However, because differing sites and different researchers often identify women properly by their birth surname, in this case, it could pose a problem. The similarities of death-year and overlap of life time-lines could be confusing.

Also:

The woman profiled here had a daughter who was named: Sarah Markle (Hallock) Gamble

In most cases:

The easiest means of identifying the woman profiled here, is that from 1846 until her death, she was properly known and referred to as Sarah Ann Hallock.

However, she frequently either signed her name or otherwise provided for documentation alternate combinations of: S.A.E. Hallock, S.A. Hallock, Sarah A.E. Hallock and Sarah Ann E. Hallock. (See Sources)

Rarely (Usually on Census forms) is she simply referred to as: Sarah Hallock. She apparently was quite fond of her full name and represented it when able to do so. Which may have been influenced by the fact she had daughter's named: Sarah and Elizabeth. It may have been her way of remaining distinguished from others in the immediate family with shared given and middle names. However, one last note.... she was using combinations of her given and middle names upon the birth certificates of some of her children, so likely she was already inclined to do so before there might be confusion as to who was who.

The Markle name was apparently quite important to Sarah Ann, because every piece of documentation I have reviewed for her children (Birth, Marriage, and Death) – each one knows her maiden name, or it is provided by their representative (ie, on death certificate transcript information (See Sources, or individual profiles). So there was no question the Markle name had an enduring presence within this specific Hallock family for at least two generations. That’s impressive considering consistent knowledge for many maiden names is lost within a generation, if known at all. Not the case here.

Compared to her spouse, James D. Hallock, depressingly very little is known by me about Sarah Ann, other than the historical record as I presently know it. I know who she was in context to being a daughter, a sister, a wife, and mother, but I have yet to know who she was as an individual.

Because so much detail exists in James D. Hallock s profile (James De Groat Hallock ) I would request you visit his profile for better insight to Sarah Ann.

Supplemental Sources:

Rootsweb Meta Search for: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle: http://worldconnect.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?surname=m...

Example of Rootsweb Profile:

Rootsweb World Connect Project / Kansas Pioneers, Including New England Ancestry:

Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle: http://worldconnect.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db...

Entries: 108363 Updated: 2016-04-17 04:31:15 UTC (Sun) Contact: Silverfox229

Home Page: Kansas Pioneers _________________________________________________________________________

Ancestors of Kansas Pioneers _________________________________________________________________________

Index | Descendancy | Register | Pedigree | Ahnentafel | Public Profile | Add Post-em _________________________________________________________________________

ID: I63861

• Name: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle
• Sex: F
• Birth: 1830 in Meaford, Grey, Ontario, Canada 1 2
• Event: "had 18 ch", 13 ch of which listed in 92 HA Link to Children 1
• Residence: 1871 St Vincent, Grey North, Ontario, Canada 3
• Death: 1898
• Name: Sarah Ann E Hallock 3
• Birth: 1831 in Ontario, Canada 3
• Name: Sarah A. Hallock 2
• Residence: 1881 Himsworth and Gurd and Pringle and Nipissing, Muskoka, Ontario, Canada 2
• Name: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Marker 4
• Name: Sarah Halleck 5
• Name: Sarah Ann Markle 6
• Name: Sarah Ann Hallock 7 8
• Name: Sarah Ann Markle Hodock 9
• Event: Clara birth record give parents: James Degroat Hallock, and Anne E Manville (Manville mashup of Marckle?) Link to Children
• _LINK: http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~births/Haa_Han_Surnames.htm Name: Anne E Manville
• _LINK: http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~births/Haa_Han_Surnames.htm
• Father: Andrew Markle b: ABT 1801 in Ontario
• Mother: Elizabeth Cook b: ABT 1794 in Ontario

Marriage: James Degroat Hallock b: 1827 in Meaford, Grey, Ontario, Canada

• Married: ABT 1847

Children

• 1. Eleanor Layton Hallock b: 1861 in Ontario, Canada
• 2. Susan Jackson Hallock b: 06 JAN 1848 in Meaford, Grey, Ontario, Canada
• 3. Elizabeth Hallock b: 1849 in Meaford, Grey, Ontario, Canada
• 4. Annie Hallock b: 1852 in Ontario, Canada
• 5. Sarah Hallock b: 1859 in Ontario, Canada
• 6. Harriet Ann Hallock b: 1855 in Meaford, Grey, Ontario, Canada
• 7. Norman Hallock b: 1857 in Ontario, Canada
• 8. Catherine Hallock b: 1863 in Ontario, Canada
• 9. James Robert Lee Hallock b: 1870 in Grey County, Ontario, Canada
• 10.Mary E Hallock b: 1869 in Ontario, Canada
• 11.Wyatt Luke Hallock b: 01 MAY 1870 in Grey County, Ontario, Canada
• 12.Minna Hallock b: OCT 1872 in Canada
• 13.Clara Hallock b: 15 FEB 1874 in Grey County, Ontario, Canada
• 14.Martha Amelia Hallock b: 11 MAY 1876 in Canada

Sources:

• Author: The Hallock Family Association

Title: Hallock Genealogy, 1992 Addendum to Publication: Name: Gateway Press; Location: Baltimore; Date: 1992;

Note: Page: WBH-1

Title: 1881 Census of Canada

Publication: Name: Date: 2009;;

Repository:

Name: www.ancestry.com

Note:

Bibliothèque et Archives Canada, Recensement canadien de 1881, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Bibliothèque et Archives Canada

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Sarah A. Hallock

Title: 1871 Census of Canada

Publication: Name: Date: 2009;;

Repository: Name: www.ancestry.com

Note: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1871, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Library and Archives Canada, n.d.

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Sarah Ann E Hallock

Author: Ancestry.com

Title: Ontario, Canada Births, 1869-1913 Publication: Name: Name: Ancestry.com Operations Inc; Location: Provo, UT, USA; Date: 2010;;

Repository: Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Wyatt Luke Hallock

Author: Ancestry.com and Genealogical Research Library (Brampton, Ontario, Canada)

Title: Ontario, Canada, Marriages, 1801-1928

Publication: Name: Date: 2010;; Repository: Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Catherine Halleck

Author: Ancestry.com

Title: Ontario, Canada Births, 1869-1913

Publication: Name: Name: Ancestry.com Operations Inc; Location: Provo, UT, USA; Date: 2010;;

Repository:

Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Clara Hallock

Author: Ancestry.com and Genealogical Research Library (Brampton, Ontario, Canada)

Title: Ontario, Canada, Marriages, 1801-1928

Publication: Name: Date: 2010;;

Repository:

Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Eloner Tayton Hallock (Misspelling of 'Elanor Layton Hallock, comment mine: jlphawn)

Author: Ancestry.com and Genealogical Research Library (Brampton, Ontario, Canada)

Title: Ontario, Canada, Marriages, 1801-1928

Publication: Name: Date: 2010;

Repository:

Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for James Robert Lee Hallock

Author: Ancestry.com and Genealogical Research Library (Brampton, Ontario, Canada)

Title: Ontario, Canada, Marriages, 1801-1928

Publication: Name: Date: 2010;

Repository: Name: www.ancestry.com

Page: Database online.

Text: Record for Sara M Hodock (Misspelling of 'Hallock', comment mine jlphawn)

Title: Ontario Birth Registrations

Text: Clara Hallock - daughter of James Degroat Hallock and Sarah Ann E Manville

===========================================================================================================================================================

Also See Broad Google Search: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle: https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&i...

===========================================================================================================================================================

Sarah Ann Elizabeth Hallock: https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&i...

FamilySearch citation of Legacy NFS Source: Sarah Ann Elizabeth Markle - Individual or family possessions: death: 1898; Carman, Manitoba, Canada

• Notes Individual or family possessions: death: 1898; Carman, Manitoba, Canada
• Individual or family possessions: burial: 1898; Carman, Manitoba, Canada

Migrated from user-supplied source citation: urn:familysearch:source:2029884776

Originally Created:

25 July 2014bybarbraphipps39

===========================================================================================================================================================

Source for this excerpt http://worldconnect.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db...

ALTON WHITNEY, HIS (James D Hallock) GRANDSON BELIEVED HE DIED IN EUGENE, OR, BUT A SEARCH
OF THE RECORDS DO NOT SUBSTANTIATE THAT. HE MADE HIS LIVING IN LATER YEARS BY SELLING BOOKS, MAINLY OF A SENSATIONAL NATURE (FOR THE TIMES ). HIS WIFE, SARAH MARKLE IS NOT BURIED IN GREENWOOD CEMETERY @ CARMEN , MAN. AS REPORTED IN THE ORIGINAL COOK GENEALOGY BOOK.

So, while the claim here for place of burial is being contested as wrong, the author offers no alternate or optional information.

===========================================================================================================================================================